The website hosting the fantasy novel contest in the other world was an external site, separate from the community, so it couldn’t be accessed via a simple link. But that didn’t matter.
“You really must write only a novel.”
“I promise.”
What I wanted wasn't the prize money—which I could never actually receive—but the chance to show them the history of our world. From their perspective, it would feel like pure fantasy.
Simply posting it in the community was enough.
“But Mr. Lee Seunghun, have you ever actually written a novel before?”
“No. But I’m not inventing a story—I’m planning to write actual history, so it’ll be fine.”
All I needed was the information and the basic writing ability to convey it.
Now that I had Sarang’s permission, I was already looking forward to the reaction.
“Lately, I’ve been reading web novels, and there’s this specific genre. One where modern inventions or history are reproduced exactly in another world, and the protagonist is praised for it.”
It was a genre where, even if the protagonist wasn't a genius, they were treated like one. By spreading the cultural power of Earth's civilization into another world, the reader could enjoy a sense of cultural superiority.
“The appeal is being able to project yourself onto a protagonist treated as a genius, satisfying your intellectual vanity, and feeling that sense of 'national pride' through the shock of the other-worlders witnessing our culture.”
“So, Mr. Lee Seunghun, do you want to feel intellectual vanity and national pride too?”
“No.”
Fortunately, the community allowed me to post simply by entering a nickname and password, without the need for a formal account.
“I’ve written countless posts in the community so far, but I’ve never once been acknowledged, have I? I want to be recognized at least once.”
“Indeed. Earth's history is fantasy to them, so if you write it well, it should get a strong response in terms of authenticity and plot development.”
“All right, then what history should I write?”
After a moment of thought, a brilliant idea came to mind.
“Since it’s a fantasy world, let’s go with European history.”
***
[Title: Review of “Joan of Arc,” a serialized community novel by “IAmADebater”]
[Author: PleaseRespectMyTaste]
A world where magic does not exist. A world where aura does not exist. A world where holy arts do not exist.
How would humanity live, and how would it develop, in such a world?
This is the basic premise of fantasy novels; we take pleasure in imagining and realizing worlds we have never seen and can never visit.
The work “Joan of Arc,” by “IAmADebater,” who is currently serializing in the community, is one such fantasy novel.
When I first encountered this novel, I was struck by a tremendous shock. It depicted with meticulous care how humanity survives in a world devoid of mana.
Good heavens! People dying of infection from a single wound because there is no healing magic!?
If there’s no healing magic, can’t they just receive healing from a priest?
What? There are gods, but not gods that actually exist—only gods that exist in the realm of faith?
So there are priests, but they can’t use holy arts?
A world without aura or magic, where war depends entirely on archers, cavalry, and spearmen.
A world where you can’t even scale a wall a few meters high without building makeshift ladders, and when the man in front dies, the one behind must simply climb over his corpse to press on.
A world where human lives are treated like flies.
A world where witches do not exist, only superstition does—and yet people still believe in it.
Even the daily inconveniences caused by the lack of utility magic were described perfectly.
I’ve read countless fantasy novels, but there has never been a work with such concrete, detailed descriptions. I nearly wet myself when I saw the illustrations the author drew personally!
Doesn’t it feel as if the author had actually lived in such a world?
Could he perhaps be a great mage who mastered the legendary dimensional magic?
Of course, dimensional magic cannot exist; every great mage who ever tried was torn apart before crossing the barrier. It’s nothing but a delusion. But the opening was so good it made me seriously entertain such thoughts.
But the moment the worldbuilding ended, those expectations were shattered to pieces.
First, the plot involves a protagonist saving a nation fallen into crisis due to war.
Since there is no magic or aura, the protagonist must become a commander and win through pure strategy and tactics alone. It should have been a classic “fantasy strategy” novel.
But the protagonist is female. Not just any woman, but a country girl.
A country girl who, as the author describes, had never received any higher education, suddenly becomes a military commander?
I thought it might be a coming-of-age story, but the process of her becoming a commander was absurd.
She claimed that the voices of God and the saints of the past commanded her to save France, her homeland.
Wait, didn’t you say this was a world without gods? Didn’t you say gods existed only in the realm of faith?
It wasn’t even foreshadowed as a hallucination or a mental breakdown. The voices were heard repeatedly, and it even led to a religious trial.
And then, unbelievably, she was recognized, met a lord, and even met the crown prince.
The crown prince, being sane, disguised a servant as himself and met the protagonist in a shabby appearance.
It was a test, and astonishingly, she saw through the disguise and showed proper courtesy to the real prince.
She’s a country girl, right? Uneducated, right? No gods, right? No aura, no magic, no holy arts, right?
After earning the crown prince’s recognition and going to war, the protagonist won victory after victory with imposing brilliance.
Let me say it again: she was a country girl. No higher education, not even basic schooling.
And yet, astonishingly! Not only did she defeat the enemy’s famed general—an educated, noble, and experienced veteran—through innate military genius, but she also fought bravely on the front lines.
By this point, I couldn’t help but curse, but there was something even more ridiculous.
In this world without magic, they use a weapon called a cannon, which fires iron balls using gunpowder.
Its power is enough to casually blow away a limb.
This formidable weapon, which showed the author’s creativity, does not work on the protagonist.
The text says a shot hit her in the head, and she was perfectly fine.
When I saw that scene, the word “fuck” escaped my lips automatically.
And when she was struck in the chest by a crossbow bolt, only to get up the next day and calmly resume commanding the army, I could only sigh in disbelief.
This woman wasn’t a character.
She was nothing more than a tool, a Mary Sue meant to satisfy the author’s sordid desires.
Still, I read to the end just so I could write this review.
After clashing with the king and being betrayed due to suspicion, the protagonist is taken prisoner, handed over to the enemy nation, and put on trial for heresy.
The author describes the priests of this world as the pinnacle of higher education—exceptionally intelligent men who are the only ones capable of holding the office.
But our country girl—again, the one with no education—saw through the logic of those priests and won the debate.
In the end, the geniuses of the age, unable to defeat her through logic, had no choice but to frame her on false charges and kill her.
To sum it up in one sentence:
What the hell kind of dogshit novel is this?
Usually, Mary Sues get a happy ending, but this ends with the protagonist being burned at the stake? A bad ending?
After finishing this, I felt a calling.
A mission to write a review and ensure no other victim like me would ever fall for this.
Finally, I’ll leave a summary for those who can't finish the whole review.
Worldbuilding: 5/5, extremely excellent and original.
Writing: 3/5, not bad, but the style is stiff—more like a history book than a novel.
Character Intelligence: 0/5, nothing but idiots. Everyone loves whatever the protagonist says. The greatest intellectuals of the age get outplayed by a country girl (lol).
Protagonist Characterization: 0/5, a tool for the author’s fantasies.
Plausibility/Realism: 0/5, the plausibility is beyond trash; it simply doesn't exist.
Overall: A novel where vanilla ice cream is topped with shit and eaten through the anus.
“Oh dear.”
Judging by the review, it seemed he didn’t like the story of Joan of Arc.
“The comments aren’t great either.”
“Mr. Lee Seunghun, the story of Joan of Arc is controversial in our world as well.”
“Still, I thought the other world would accept it to some extent.”
Because it was a fantasy world.
I thought stories with fantasy elements would be more popular, but they were surprisingly picky.
“Maybe I should have written a different story.”
“How about a Korean story? After investigating their writings, I confirmed that a sense of Orientalism toward the Eastern continent still remains.”
“A fusion of Orientalism and fantasy literature, huh. Not bad.”
Then what should I write?
“If it’s a war in Korea, then it has to be that one.”
I pressed the writing button.
“The Imjin War.”
I began typing.
“General Yi Sun-sin.”
***
[Title: Immortal Yi Sun-sin Episode 1: Yi Sun-sin]
[Author: IAmADebater]
[Comments]
[Oh, what’s this?]
[A fantasy novel with an Eastern vibe? I can't resist lol]
[Wait, isn’t this the same author as the Joan of Arc one? Hmm……]
[Should I even read this? The author is kind of…]
[The worldbuilding is insane. Did he actually include illustrations?]
[This is amazing. First time seeing such a cool Eastern setting. But is it medieval fantasy again?]
[The serialization speed is wild. He’ll probably write ten chapters a day.]
[This is crazy. I’ll let myself be fooled one more time.]
***
[Title: Immortal Yi Sun-sin Episode 7: Passing the Military Exam]
[Author: IAmADebater]
[Comments]
[At last! Finally, the unemployment is over!]
[Wasn’t this supposed to be a slice-of-life story? Why is he suddenly becoming a soldier?]
└[Isn’t that just because he kept trying and failing all this time?]
[I think the protagonist chose the wrong career path. There’s no way someone who failed until age 32 is suited for the military, right?]
[Hmm, I don’t really like it when a slice-of-life story suddenly turns into a workplace drama.]
[Still, it was slice-of-life up to episode 7, so it’ll probably stay that way, right?]
[The title is Immortal Yi Sun-sin, isn’t it? Maybe the goal is for him to go through various journeys and actually become an immortal?]
└[Is that even possible in a fantasy world? Isn’t that hard even in our world?]
└[What’s so hard about it? Just become an ascender. Become a demigod. Eat a dragon heart. Become a lich.]
└[You’re a Lee Pyeong, aren’t you? lol]
***
[Title: Immortal Yi Sun-sin Episode 10: Wae-gu]
[Author: IAmADebater]
[Comments]
[So at last, the enemy invasion begins in earnest.]
[It was fun watching the protagonist rise through the military exam.]
[So the slice-of-life is over now.]
[He was falsely accused, forced into civilian service, and just when he was finally about to get promoted at lightning speed, it suddenly drifts into a war story?]
└[What are you talking about? Did he earn those promotions by rolling dice? He got them by fighting battles. It was a war story from the start.]
[I like how they make a disgraced general serve as an ordinary soldier to make him reflect on his mistakes. We should adopt civilian service too.]
└[Novels are novels. They don’t have magic or aura, so the burden is lighter. But for us? How would you feel if a great mage came to brew your coffee? Could you sleep if an aura master was on night duty? Could you walk past if an archbishop were cleaning the hallway?]
└[Oh shit, that’s horrifying……]
***
[Title: Immortal Yi Sun-sin Episode 12: Battle of Tangeumdae]
[Author: IAmADebater]
[Comments]
[????]
[Great??? General???]
[This is insane lol. I can’t tell whether the arquebus is that amazing or whether the so-called 'great general' is just pathetic.]
[The nation’s greatest general gets deleted in a single battle! lolㅋㅋㅋㅋ Is someone who doesn’t even properly check the enemy’s weapons really a great general?]
└[He probably knew. There’s a description. But it seems he didn’t think much of it.]
└[He even said, “Is something called an arquebus guaranteed to hit just because it’s fired?” Didn’t you read the novel properly? He knew and ignored it.]
[But why fight with a river at your back? They don’t even have flight magic, so isn’t this just cornering themselves?]
└[There’s no clear description, so I don’t know.]
└[Don’t you get it from the dialogue? It means they fought with the river at their backs, prepared to die together with the enemy.]
└[Maybe they were fighting so frantically that it just happened by chance?]
└[They were hastily gathered soldiers, so they may have lacked training and the orders got tangled during battle.]
[Don’t be too hard on the commander. When you fight a weapon you’ve never seen before, especially when its power is beyond imagination, defeat is inevitable.]
└[Exactly. What did the Holy Kingdom say when the Wraith King first created the zombie legion? “That measly zombie nonsense can be melted instantly by our holy arts!” And the result? The entire 100,000-strong vanguard became zombie food, right?]
[In my opinion, it’s the commander’s personality. Look at the description. Too rough, too arrogant. He doesn’t scout properly, looks down on the Japanese as barbarians, underestimates the arquebus, and because the fortress is small, he just charges out. There are more than enough reasons for him to lose. It’s stranger that he won.]
[But an arquebus—couldn’t that actually be made?]
└[From the description alone, a mana bullet seems stronger anyway.]
└[It’d be perfect as a toy.]
└[True lol. This author’s imagination is really good, with both the cannon and the arquebus.]
└[Aren’t both of them gunpowder weapons? Maybe the author’s job is an alchemist?]
[What do we do about Seonjo ㅜㅜ]
└[The best ally who crushed all the ministers’ objections and got our Sun-sin promoted at lightning speed!]
└[If it’s Seonjo, maybe he’ll come up with some scheme?]
└[He’s a capable ruler. He’ll definitely devise some stratagem.]
└[For real, based on what he’s shown so far, he’s definitely top-tier as a ruler, so he won’t just get taken down like this. He’ll probably use the protagonist and the other generals well and drag it into a long war.]
***
[Title: Immortal Yi Sun-sin Episode 13: Burning Hanyang]
[Author: IAmADebater]
[Comments]
[ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ]
[ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ]
[ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ]
[Run! Run! Run! Run away! Runrunrun!]
[Is this for real lolㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ]
[The monarch lolㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ abandoning the fortress lolㅋㅋㅋㅋ abandoning the people lolㅋㅋㅋㅋ run lolㅋㅋㅋㅋ]
[Why is he fleeing so disgracefully lolㅋㅋㅋㅋ]
[Author, is this right? The character has collapsed in just one chapter.]
└[For real, isn’t this way too sudden? There were already some weak points, but he wasn’t this much of a total failure.]
└[Aside from his woman problems, there weren’t any major flaws, right? But now you’re making him this pathetic?]
[What are these people talking about? If the king is captured, the country is finished. Running away is the correct move. Fleeing is the right thing to do. Everyone’s too emotional to think properly.]
└[That’s true. It is true, but at least he should move strategically. He didn’t even use scorched-earth tactics, handed all military authority to his son, and then kept heading north until he tried to cross into Ming. Anyone can see he’s just thrashing around to save his own skin.]
└[It’s not a strategic move, it’s a survival move, and the people can all see it. If the king does this, his authority gets shredded. Even in our world that would be bad—how much worse would it be in fantasy?]
[The son is the only one who’s truly pitiful. Staying in a country that lost its capital in his late teens and serving as the supreme military authority? I’d understand if he jumped into a river right now.]
[So when does our Sun-sin show up?]
***
[Title: Immortal Yi Sun-sin Episode 16: God of Naval Warfare]
[Author: IAmADebater]
[Comments]
[Wow! Yi Sun-sin!]
[Sun-sin is doing great!]
[Victory after victory! He doesn’t know defeat!]
[What is the turtle ship! What is that turtle shape! What is that aesthetic sense!]
└[I’m a dwarf, and I’m planning to make a panokseon first, then a turtle ship hehe]
└[I’m looking forward to it being built.]
└[Where are you building it? If you’re launching a ship, it has to be somewhere other than the north, right? Let’s build it together.]
[The importance of reconnaissance is really clear here.]
└[Do you see this, Shin Rip? This is how important reconnaissance is.]
[But why is the Japanese navy so weak?]
└[Unlike land battles, they can’t even do anything]
└[Isn’t it just that Yi Sun-sin is amazing?]
└[Hmm, thinking about this author’s previous work, I’m worried he’s doing a Mary Sue again……]
└[What Mary Sue? If that were the case, would he have only become a soldier in his thirties? He’d have done it long ago, right?]
└[Probably, right?]
[I came so hard at the crane-wing formation]
└[For real, the way he lured them in, then instantly switched to the offensive and deployed the formation was insanely cool.]
└[How is he so perfectly coordinated without even communication magic? Isn’t this fantasy a bit too much?]
└[It’s a novel, have a drink lol]
[But what’s the point of winning a naval battle? They’re getting crushed on land anyway.]
└[Because the supply lines get cut, idiot]
└[Can you fight without eating?]
└[Even if they want to plunder, the righteous militia keeps fighting, so it’s hard]
[The fact that they’re spotlighting Won Gyun makes me uneasy]
└[The way he acts really reeks of total failure]
└[He’ll probably cause trouble soon]
***
[Title: Immortal Yi Sun-sin Episode 19: Dismissal]
[Author: IAmADebater]
[Comments]
[ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ]
[Plague, famine, desertion—a whole combo set lolㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ]
[Author, did you change the story after reading the comments? Are you doing this on purpose because it was going too smoothly? It’s so obvious lolㅋㅋㅋㅋ]
[Author, Seonjo’s characterization has completely collapsed.]
└[Wasn’t Yi Sun-sin the general Seonjo chose? He liked him so much, and now that he’s actually doing well, he’s jealous?]
└[No matter how strong his lust for power is, does this make sense during wartime, especially when the country is on the verge of collapse?]
└[This is a bit…… too forced.]
[You ruined one character just to cram in hardship somehow]
└[For real, Seonjo wasn’t this much of a failure. To force in hardship, he falls for enemy schemes even when he knows they’re a trick, grows jealous of Yi Sun-sin, subtly needles him, and now he tortures and dismisses him on false charges of treason because he won’t go into a battle he can’t win?]
└[The author’s skill is starting to show, huh? Plausibility shattered, huh? Realism falling apart, huh?]
[Ease up on the misery. I’ve already eaten a truckload of misery watching plague and famine destroy everything, and now even the king is acting up?]
└[When are you giving us the payoff?]
└[I feel like I’m going to choke to death!]
***
[Title: Immortal Yi Sun-sin Episode 23: Won Gyun]
[Author: IAmADebater]
[Comments]
[Fuck lolㅋㅋㅋㅋ]
[He ruined everything lolㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ]
[There’s nothing left lolㅋㅋㅋㅋ]
[Am I the only one who cried at the scene where the protagonist’s mother came to meet him and died on the way?]
└[I cried too. It was so damn sad]
└[I cried with the protagonist when he said he couldn’t even hold a funeral for her]
[No, seriously, author, please pay attention to plausibility. You said Seonjo had a good eye for talent, right? But then he suddenly goes blackened and loses that eye too? To the point of handing all naval command to Won Gyun? Did his abilities just vanish?]
└[So in the end, he ruined everything, huh? Tasty, huh?]
└[You should stop. It just looks like you’re desperately turning one character into trash and fighting a war of nerves with the readers.]
***
[Title: Immortal Yi Sun-sin Episode 24: Reinstatement]
[Author: IAmADebater]
[Comments]
[After all that, now they’re asking the protagonist for help again]
└[Wow, they reinstated him, but his rank got demoted by four levels lolㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ]
[At this point, I’m starting to dislike the protagonist too. Why is he just being treated like a pushover?]
└[Honestly, the people like him, the legitimacy is on his side, and he handles the military well—just stage a rebellion already.]
└[I get that being loyal is good, but he just looks too much like a pushover. After being fed so much misery, all I can think is that I want him to blow up spectacularly.]
└[Author, calm down. You’re making me furious.]
[Even though he couldn’t hold a funeral for his mother, he’s mourning in mourning clothes, and the king gifts him meat lol]
└[Isn’t there a culture of not eating meat during mourning?]
└[The king couldn’t possibly not know that, so doing it anyway is just blatant t-bagging, right?]
└[I can’t take this anymore.]
└[I can’t take it either. I’m dropping this, fuck]
[Author, you’re planning to explode with a huge payoff later, right? You’re going to kill that bastard Seonjo and make Sun-sin king, right? That’s why you’re building up the mana now, right? I believe in you.]
***
[Title: Immortal Yi Sun-sin Episode 26: Battle of Myeongnyang]
[Author: IAmADebater]
[Comments]
[Hah, is this right?]
[Is this correct? Author?]
[So you’re saying 12 ships defeated 330 enemy ships? What I saw was real?]
└[Now the author can’t even write battle scenes properly.]
└[He’s just going off the rails. You can see he’s lost affection for the work.]
[Author, how do you beat 330 ships with 12? This isn’t a matter of command, it’s a matter of common sense.]
└[I told you, this is a war of nerves. We said a few things and now he’s ruining his own work just to act out.]
└[Hah, I really enjoyed it even when other people complained, but I’m starting to lose interest……]
[Did he use 12 ships to encircle and annihilate them? Did he cast illusion magic? Did the Blue Dragon support him from beneath the sea?]
└[Is this not going to end with “Actually, Yi Sun-sin was a great mage who used dimensional magic to visit another world.”?]
└[That would be an all-time drift lol]
[ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ The author’s habit is showing again, right? Making the protagonist a Mary Sue and having him mow everything down as a munchkin—that’s this author’s trademark, isn’t it?]
└[He did it in the previous work too, and he’s doing it again in this one.]
└[The previous work at least had occasional defeats. But this one? He’s undefeated so far lolㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ]
└[An invincible great general who has never once been defeated, yet the king desperately wants to kill him, yet that same king appointed him, then expelled him, then called him back, then keeps t-bagging him after calling him back—Author, please choose one. Who lives like this? The king acts like this and the ministers just sit there? Realistically, this is impossible.]
[Still, the ending will be a happy one, right?]
***
[Title: Immortal Yi Sun-sin Episode 28: Do Not Tell the Enemy of My Death -End-]
[Author: IAmADebater]
[Comments]
[You fucking piece of shit author, where do you live?]
[You fed us misery like crazy and then killed the protagonist and ended it?]
[Do not tell the enemy of my death? You shouldn’t have told us either.]
[Wriiiiiiiiter!!!!!!!! Fuck!!!!!!!!]
[Honestly, if this were actual history, I’d have been impressed. I might have been moved by a loyal subject who stayed faithful to the nation to the end even while the king was jealous and acting like a bastard. But this is a novel! It’s a novel, so how does it make sense to develop it like this and end it like this!]
[At first it was slice-of-life, then it was a winning streak, then suddenly a misery drift, then every kind of misery imaginable, a war of nerves with the readers, the collapse of the characters he created himself, and the ending is the protagonist’s death, and that’s it? That’s it? That’s it? You fucking bastard, is a novel a joke to you?]
[So this is a time machine. I thought I’d gone back to the rental-shop era. People who read a lot of novels back then know this, but sad endings were common in those days.]
└[I know. It was the era when the heroine got raped, the parents died, the protagonist was terminally ill, and the ending was death.]
└[There was really such a time? Seriously?]
└[That’s how it was back then. You’d go to rescue the heroine after all that trouble, only to find her already a dead corpse, heroine NTR happened all the time, and with all kinds of bullshit stacked against him the protagonist would mentally break down and go insane.]
[Please, never write again]
[Please never write again]
[Don’t write novels, fuck]
[If all you’re going to do with that writing skill and creativity is churn out landmines like this, then don’t write!!!]
***
[IP blocked by the manager.]
[Reason: Fed the readers misery like crazy and gave no payoff, fought a war of nerves with the readers, no plausibility, only likes Mary Sues, severe character collapse, ruined the ending.]
[Block duration: 999,999,999 years]
***
“Ah.”
So this is what real history was like.
“I got blocked again.”
Comments (0)
Please log in to leave a comment. Login or Register