The cheers that had filled the training yard gradually subsided.
Daemon stood with his halberd across his shoulder, watching Arthur Dayne for a long while.
He had lost.
There was no excuse to make.
It was not that he lacked strength, nor that his weapon had been at a disadvantage. He was the larger and stronger man, and the halberd's reach gave him an advantage over Arthur's single sword. In the final exchanges, he had thought he had truly driven his opponent to the edge of the yard.
And still, he had lost.
One half-step Arthur had taken at the final instant had overturned everything.
Daemon looked at the spot where he had stood moments before and slowly narrowed his eyes. More than displeasure at defeat, the fight had already begun again in his head: Arthur's changing stride and sword position whenever he retreated, the subtle changes in his response after Daemon altered his grip, the gap he had seemingly left open at the end, and the shift in Daemon's center of balance as he lunged toward it.
Next time, I will not fall for it.
The thought came easily.
Then another followed.
But that old man will not do the same thing next time, either.
The corner of Daemon's mouth lifted slightly.
Then Arthur would use another method.
Daemon only had to see it.
See it.
Think.
Correct it again.
He liked strong people.
More precisely, he liked people from whom he could learn.
It might sound rather strange to say he felt good after being beaten by someone better than himself, but a man who had spent too long in graduate school had standards for enjoyment that had strayed somewhat from the ordinary.
"Lord Seadrake."
Arthur approached first.
His breathing had not entirely settled, either. He was faintly conscious of the side that had taken the end of Daemon's halberd shaft, but his expression held more interest than discomfort.
Daemon handed the halberd to an attendant.
"Did you deliberately give me an opening at the end?"
A question came before any greeting.
Arthur gave a short laugh.
"For the last few steps, yes."
"From the beginning?"
"Not to that extent."
Daemon nodded.
He liked that answer better. Had Arthur claimed to foresee all his reactions from the beginning, Daemon would have been somewhat doubtful. Men fighting one another was not like moving pieces upon a board. The opponent thought as well; plans formed at the outset went awry after only a few exchanges. What mattered in the end was not a perfect plan, but what one did after the plan went wrong.
Arthur spoke.
"There was something that surprised me as well."
"What was that?"
"You kept changing."
Daemon's brows rose slightly.
"At first, you used your strength and reach. When I began giving ground, you changed your grip. Once I stopped evading twice in the same direction, you began limiting the space in which I could move before I moved at all."
Arthur took a moment to catch his breath.
"It is uncommon to find someone who corrects what he has seen in the very next exchange."
Daemon did not bother with false modesty.
"I still lost."
"That was why you were more dangerous."
"What?"
"I mean that if we fought once more, I could not confidently say I would defeat you by the same method."
Favorability increased.
He was strong.
He was humble.
They could even speak to one another.
There was no reason to dislike him.
Then Daemon felt a gaze from the side.
He turned his head.
It was Jaime.
More precisely, Jaime was not looking at Daemon.
He was looking at Arthur Dayne.
His eyes shone.
Daemon watched Jaime silently for a moment, but Jaime did not even notice the gaze upon him.
It was an expression Daemon rarely saw during his lessons. Jaime had never looked that way when Daemon spoke of taxes, nor when he explained how logistics decided wars. Even when Daemon had taught him swordsmanship by taking up a wooden sword and personally thrashing him, Jaime might have looked impressed, but never as though bewitched by the very person before him.
Yet one spar with Arthur Dayne, and there he was.
Daemon narrowed his eyes.
...This little bastard?
It was a trivial thing.
Which made it all the more irritating.
Daemon did not think he was jealous.
It was not truly that sort of feeling.
He merely developed the wholly reasonable concern, as an educator, that perhaps he had relaxed Jaime's instruction rather too much over the past few weeks while preparing for the crown prince's visit.
Ten years old.
He liked swords.
He liked tales of knights.
And before his eyes stood one of the Seven Kingdoms' foremost swordsmen.
These are poor conditions.
Recent progress.
History.
Finances.
Logistics.
Practical training in lordship.
It was time to make him review the harbor ledgers again, and there were still several warehouses Jaime had not inspected himself.
He has been getting lax lately.
The second revision of Jaime Lannister's educational plan quietly began to take shape.
Jaime, knowing nothing, continued watching Arthur.
Arthur seemed to notice that gaze as well.
"The young Lannister lord."
"Yes. I am teaching him at present."
"I know."
Daemon looked at him.
"You do?"
"His Highness the crown prince spoke of you often."
Often.
Daemon went still for a moment.
To Arthur, it was likely a remark of no consequence.
"Having met you in person, I think I understand a little of why His Highness holds you in such high regard."
Daemon did not answer.
Instead, he looked around once.
The crown prince's retinue.
Young knights.
Sons of noble houses.
Among the faces he was seeing for the first time today, not a few were watching him with peculiar interest. He recalled the looks that had been cast at him when he first welcomed Rhaegar that afternoon.
Daemon was not utterly incapable of reading the currents between people.
Given one clue, the scattered pieces swiftly fell into place.
Rhaegar had sent letters for four years.
Daemon had sent replies.
For Daemon, that was the end of it.
He had no reason to go around telling others what those letters contained.
Apparently Rhaegar had not felt the same.
Ah.
The smile at Daemon's lips hardened ever so slightly.
That bastard Rhaegar has been running his mouth.
On reflection, it was not especially strange. To Daemon, Rhaegar was a pen pal, and Daemon was one to Rhaegar. But Daemon was not the sort to recount interesting discussions with a friend to others, whereas Rhaegar seemed to have no particular reluctance to share interesting people and interesting conversations with those he kept close.
That small difference had accumulated over four years.
As a result, Daemon had become a man already somewhat known to people he was meeting for the first time today.
"Does His Highness... speak of me often?"
Arthur considered briefly.
"Yes."
It was brief.
Which made it all the more certain.
Daemon did not close his eyes.
He only wanted to.
*
That evening, Daemon experienced firsthand that the guess he had formed during the day was almost entirely correct.
Not long after the feast began, people started coming to him. At first it was bearable. They praised the blue-and-white porcelain they had seen earlier, Daemon offered suitable thanks, and the conversation naturally turned to practical matters: whether he intended to establish similar workshops in the south, whether more Sea Dragon Point goods could be distributed southward, whether he planned to increase fertilizer production.
That much was all right.
It was business talk.
Business had prices and quantities, production costs and transport costs, and what the other party wanted was generally clear.
The problem was that people came without end.
When one withdrew, another who had been listening nearby approached. While Daemon spoke with that person, another thought of a fresh question; once he answered it, someone standing a little farther away heard and approached again.
A wave upon wave of questions began crashing over Daemon.
At first, he answered diligently.
A little later, he answered adequately.
Later still, his answers became shorter.
"I think we must observe production a little longer before deciding that."
He smiled.
The muscles around his mouth felt slightly stiff.
"In the long term, I will consider it."
It was not a lie.
He could consider it.
Then, after considering it, he could decline to do it.
The other party withdrew with a satisfied expression.
Daemon did not miss that moment.
He set down his cup.
He surveyed his surroundings.
To the left.
People.
To the right.
People.
People ahead as well.
Still, he could see at least one path to the door.
Daemon began to move with utmost naturalness.
At least, it seemed natural to him.
One step.
His eyes met someone's.
He smiled.
Another step.
Just a little farther, and he would reach the corridor.
Once in the corridor, the solar, the library, anywhere would do. He could simply say he had urgent business. Lords were meant to have much urgent business.
Perfect.
"Daemon."
His feet stopped.
Daemon slowly turned his head.
Valena was speaking with a noblewoman some distance away. A gentle smile rested on her face, and her lips continued conversing with the woman, but her eyes were fixed precisely upon her son.
She said nothing.
She did not need to.
Go back.
Daemon understood.
There was no flaw in his ability to take a hint.
His weakness lay only in the ability to deal with what came after in a socially graceful fashion.
"...Yes, Mother."
Valena resumed her conversation.
Daemon turned back as well.
At that moment, his eyes met Raymund's from across the room.
Having lived alongside him for many years, the old man understood what had happened at once.
The corners of his mouth rose.
He did not help.
Instead, he raised the cup in his hand just slightly.
Daemon stared at him for a moment.
Traitor.
Thus his first attempt at escape ended in less than a minute.
The questions resumed.
Daemon smiled.
He answered.
He smiled again.
Sometimes he evaded firm commitments, and when someone carried on at length alone, he began employing the advanced technique of keeping a conversation going simply by nodding at appropriate moments.
He had been a lord for twelve years.
There had been some growth.
He simply did not enjoy it.
Daemon was not someone incapable of understanding people. On the contrary, he was rather quick to read subtle shifts in faces and voices, silences wedged between words, and the direction of another's gaze.
So long as romance was not involved.
Unfortunately, after meeting Kim Jaebong in his former life and entering graduate school, that particular sense had deteriorated considerably. It was not that he had never had a girlfriend. He had merely been cuckolded after beginning graduate school.
After that, Daemon had unintentionally become a thorough believer in devoted love.
His skill with romance had not recovered.
Then Daemon's gaze met that of a man.
Red hair.
A young face.
The heir to Griffin's Roost.
Jon Connington.
They had already been introduced.
He had been described as one of the nobles close to Rhaegar.
When their eyes met, Jon immediately bowed with proper courtesy, and Daemon returned the gesture in kind.
It was an impeccable greeting.
Yet something was strange.
A very thin chill passed along the back of Daemon's neck.
Daemon looked at Connington again.
He was already conversing with someone else.
He was not glaring.
Nor was his expression discourteous.
And yet.
...He dislikes me.
That much Daemon could tell.
The problem was why.
They had met for the first time today.
He had never traded directly with House Connington.
He did not recall cheating them of coin, causing Griffin's Roost losses, or, much less, beating up anyone connected to them.
Daemon searched his memories for a moment.
Nothing emerged.
Daemon's instincts for romance were not sharp enough to discover that the reason lay in Jon Connington's feelings toward Rhaegar Targaryen.
Had he known—and realized that he appeared to be a kind of rival for Rhaegar's affections—Daemon would have recoiled in horror for an entirely different reason.
The man concerned did not know.
So he soon reached a conclusion.
Well, if he dislikes me, he dislikes me.
There was no reason every person in the world had to love him.
Then another noble approached.
Daemon smiled again.
It was more awkward than before.
*
When the feast ended, Daemon felt as though he had fought a war.
And it was the kind of war he hated most.
A war where he could not strike the enemy.
Could not flee.
And had to keep smiling until it ended.
As night deepened, the castle gradually grew quieter. The crown prince's retinue, northern nobles, knights and attendants, and far more servants and horses than usual filled the castle; today, of all days, Aspera could not come near.
Daemon had been thinking that since before sunset.
As Aspera grew, the bond between them had changed somewhat from what it once was. When she was young, voice and gesture had been needed. But as time together accumulated and the dragon grew, simple feelings or intentions sometimes came through faintly even at greater distances than before.
They were not words.
Nor were sentences heard inside his mind.
Too indistinct to call commands, yet possessing more direction than simple emotions.
Far away.
Do not come today.
That much.
Aspera understood.
At least, Daemon felt she did.
The sense of that immense presence somewhere far out at sea gradually receded.
For the two of them, that was enough.
Late that night, Daemon was finally alone in his solar.
The silence that came after hearing human voices all day was sweeter than he had expected.
Only a small lamp burned upon the table.
Daemon sank deep into his chair and opened a book.
He read several lines.
Then went back upward.
He could not remember what he had just read.
He read it again.
This time it entered his mind.
Before long, his concentration returned.
Even reading felt like rest.
Then the lamp flame flickered once.
Daemon looked at it without thinking.
It was dark.
Candlelight and oil lamps had a romance of their own, but they were not very kind to human eyes.
Electric bulbs...
His thoughts strayed sideways.
Carbonized plant fibers.
A filament.
A vacuum.
Lead-in wires.
Glass sealing.
And above all, a stable power source.
Thinking of one thing brought five more in its wake.
Daemon shook his head.
Later.
He already had more than enough underway.
He returned his gaze to the book.
A little while later.
Knock, knock.
Someone knocked at the door.
Daemon lifted his eyes from the book.
He was not surprised.
He had expected someone to come.
That was why two cups had been on the table from the beginning.
"Come in."
The door opened.
Silver hair appeared first, silhouetted against the dim light of the corridor.
It was Rhaegar Targaryen.
Daemon rose and gave a courteous bow.
"Your Highness."
Rhaegar's gaze fell upon the two cups on the table.
"Did you know I would come?"
"To some extent."
"How?"
"Considering how you behaved this afternoon."
Rhaegar smiled faintly.
"There were too many eyes upon us in the daytime. I had much I wished to say, but I restrained myself greatly."
Daemon said nothing for a moment.
Restrained himself.
The man who had personally raised a kneeling vassal before dozens of onlookers, called him by name rather than title, and taken both his hands to announce their reunion after four years to the entire world now claimed to have exercised considerable restraint.
Several curses rose to Daemon's throat.
He swallowed every one.
Then he smiled.
"It seems Your Highness makes it easy for those around you to notice when you meet someone you are glad to see."
It was, in its own way, a very indirect phrasing.
Rhaegar thought for a moment.
"Perhaps I do."
Daemon's smile stiffened by a hair.
He did not understand.
"I see."
"Did it make you uncomfortable?"
That question, at least, was sincere.
Daemon looked at Rhaegar's face.
He was handsome.
He had the sort of face that could be crowned and placed in a storybook illustration without seeming out of place; his voice was gentle, and when he sensed the possibility that he might have erred, he asked whether the other person was uncomfortable before offering excuses.
He was a man whom it was harder not to like.
"No."
Daemon spoke at last.
"If Your Highness was pleased, that is enough."
Rhaegar smiled.
Daemon smiled back.
Inside, he wept a little.
There is no getting through to him.
Daemon decided he would hear him out and send him back at a reasonable hour.
That conclusion did not last long.
For the first thing Rhaegar raised after sitting down was the afternoon's spar.
"Your match with Ser Arthur was impressive."
"You saw it?"
"Yes."
Daemon searched his memory.
There had been many people around the training yard, but he did not remember Rhaegar's silver hair.
"I do not think you were there."
"I was a little farther back."
Rhaegar smiled.
"Everyone was watching you and Ser Arthur. There was no reason for me to step forward and draw attention, was there?"
That was true.
The moment the crown prince stepped forward, perhaps half the gazes would have turned elsewhere.
"Thanks to that, I watched without interruption."
As Rhaegar accepted a cup, he gave Daemon a brief look from head to toe.
Daemon noticed.
"What is it?"
"You are very different from what I imagined."
"You saw me in person four years ago."
"You were twelve then."
That was true as well.
"And from your letters, I imagined someone somewhat more sedate."
Daemon looked down at himself.
Nearly two meters tall.
Broader shoulders.
Thicker arms.
That afternoon, those arms had swung a halberd and driven Arthur Dayne to the edge of the training yard.
"I did not often write letters about swinging halberds."
Rhaegar laughed.
"I see."
"What sort of person did Your Highness think I would be?"
"A man who sits before a desk for long hours."
"That is true."
"A man who would stay awake all night checking a single record if something in it seemed wrong."
"That is true as well."
"A man who could not simply let it pass if someone cited an incorrect record."
Daemon fell silent briefly.
"...That is true too."
Rhaegar's smile deepened slightly.
"I did not expect such a man to be beating Ser Arthur Dayne with a halberd."
"I was the one being beaten."
"If one saw it to the end, it would be difficult to put it only that way."
Rhaegar did not look as though he was offering empty praise.
"You nearly drove him into a corner."
"Nearly is not victory."
"Still, you have the look of a man who learned much."
Daemon looked at him.
"You can see that too?"
"We have exchanged letters for four years."
Rhaegar set down his cup.
"You seem less like a man who grows angry when he fails, and more like one who becomes pleased when he discovers why he failed."
Daemon was silent for a moment.
It was accurate.
More accurate than he expected.
...This is why talking with him is troublesome.
It was troublesome.
But it was interesting.
That was the problem.
Only moments ago Daemon had intended to send the crown prince away at an appropriate hour, yet now he was leaning deep into his chair.
"So what did you think as you watched the spar?"
"At first, I thought you were far larger than I had expected."
"..."
"Then I thought Ser Arthur would win."
"That is somewhat unpleasant to hear."
Rhaegar laughed.
Some of the tension left over from the day eased within the room.
The conversation that began so moved from knights and weapons to war, then from war to old kings and ancient records.
At first, it was a discussion of history.
At least, at first.
Rhaegar spoke of an old record he had seen at Winterfell. It concerned one winter of the Age of Heroes, and he said there were considerable differences between chronicles compiled in the south and traditions remaining in the North.
Daemon asked,
"Did you verify when it was written?"
"Not its precise date. But it was written at least several decades after the time when the event is said to have occurred."
"Then it is not an eyewitness account."
"No."
Rhaegar nodded.
"That is why I did not place much faith in it at first."
Daemon's brows rose slightly.
He was different from four years ago.
The Rhaegar of old had been a man who, upon finding an ancient sentence, first considered what that sentence meant.
Now he first asked who had left it, when, and why.
"I looked for other records addressing the same event. I considered who the authors were, and where possible, I looked into who had patronized those who left the records."
"Even their patrons?"
"You said it yourself."
Rhaegar spoke.
"That those who record things have interests of their own."
He had.
A royal chronicle might favor the king.
A sept's record might contain the interests of the Faith.
That the victor's records were more likely to survive did not make them necessarily true.
Daemon recalled writing all that, almost tediously, over several letters.
"You remembered."
"Because it was interesting."
For Rhaegar, that seemed to be all there was to it.
It was interesting, so he remembered.
Daemon was a little impressed.
He doubted records.
He checked when they were written.
He considered their authors.
He compared different sources.
He did not discard unfavorable accounts.
That was the method Daemon had fed him piece by piece through letters over the past four years.
He grew well.
Daemon felt strangely proud.
For a moment, he forgot that Rhaegar was older than he was.
The conversation drifted toward an older age still.
The age of kings.
The age of heroes.
An age where the boundary between records and oral tradition was blurred.
And around then, the discussion gradually began to leave the realm of history.
A winter without end.
The Long Night.
Something descending from the North.
Tales that the dead had walked.
A hero bearing fire.
A red sword.
Dragons.
Names differed from region to region, as did details. In some traditions the hero was a king, in others an unnamed warrior. Some called fire a gift from a god, while others linked it to dragons.
Daemon said,
"Similar circumstances may produce similar stories."
"I thought so as well."
Rhaegar agreed too easily.
Daemon's gaze rose a little.
"So I tried, as much as possible, to consider separately the traditions most likely to have branched from a common root."
"...Yes."
"I also considered that merchants and sailors might have carried tales with them."
It could not be wholly ruled out.
Centuries.
Perhaps thousands of years.
With stories reaching back so far, it was impossible even to prove every exchange between one person and another.
Yet there were things that remained repeated even after stripping away as much as possible.
Darkness.
Fire.
Smoke.
Salt.
And then.
"There is also the phrase, 'waking dragons from stone.'"
Daemon's fingers stopped over his cup.
He thought of the cave by the sea.
The egg hardened like stone.
The faint life he had first felt.
The little black-and-red dragon that had broken free of its shell.
Aspera.
...Wait.
A slight shiver ran over him.
Daemon promptly corrected his thinking.
It had been a dragon egg.
A dragon had come from the dragon egg.
Aside from the egg being so old it had appeared hardened like stone, there was no reason to find it strange.
That is rational.
It was not wrong, either.
Still, it was quite strange that one of the symbols Rhaegar had been seeking through old records and distant traditions was already sitting across from him.
Daemon had awakened a dragon from an egg hardened like stone.
He was also betrothed to a wolf of the North.
But Rhaegar was looking too far away.
And Daemon could not see what lay too close.
Neither knew it.
"It is interesting."
Rhaegar's eyes brightened slightly.
Daemon immediately regretted it.
Ah, fuck.
I should not have shown interest.
Even as he thought it, his body was already inclining a little toward the table.
"How old is that record?"
The conversation continued long after.
Whenever Rhaegar brought out a record, Daemon questioned its weak points first. A late date of composition might mean later additions; recurring words did not necessarily describe the same event; war, migration, and trade might have mixed traditions together.
Rhaegar answered each point.
What he did not know, he said he did not know.
What was uncertain, he distinguished as uncertain.
For objections he had already considered, he produced the materials he had found.
At first, Daemon was satisfied.
Oh.
A little later.
Ohhh.
Later still.
...He has grown a great deal, has he not?
He had plainly improved.
Yet after listening for a long while, Daemon began to feel a tiny sense of unease.
Rhaegar doubted records.
He sought counterarguments.
He read materials unfavorable to his own views.
There was no great fault in his method.
But beneath all his examination was one premise.
All these records ultimately pointed to one thing.
And that thing was not unrelated to his royal house.
Rhaegar doubted almost everything.
Everything except that premise.
Daemon watched him for a while before speaking.
"Your Highness."
"Speak."
"May I ask a somewhat discourteous question?"
Rhaegar smiled faintly.
"When you say that, the question is generally not a comfortable one."
"Then shall I not ask it?"
"No."
Rhaegar set down his cup.
"I will hear it."
Daemon chose his words for a moment.
"Are you presently seeking an answer?"
Rhaegar's expression changed slightly.
"Or," Daemon said, "are you confirming that the answer you already possess is right?"
The room grew quiet.
Rhaegar did not reply at once.
"You think I have already decided upon the conclusion I desire."
"I am saying that may be possible."
"I have considered it myself."
This time, Daemon was slightly surprised.
Rhaegar slowly turned his cup between his fingers.
"Whether I am seeing only what I wish to see."
After a moment, he continued.
"Whether I am forcing commonalities upon records that have no relation to one another."
"And?"
"I sought out still more records that did not accord with my thinking."
"Yet your view did not change."
"The opposite."
His certainty had grown stronger.
Daemon thought briefly to himself.
He has already decided the answer.
But he soon realized that phrase was not quite right. Men who decided their answers usually discarded unfavorable evidence.
Rhaegar brought it in.
Read it.
Refuted it.
At times, corrected his own thinking.
And still arrived at the same place.
That was a problem somewhat different from foolishness.
Rhaegar said,
"I will ask you one thing as well."
"Please do."
"If records continually appear pointing in the same direction."
Rhaegar looked into Daemon's eyes.
"Is it more rational to turn away from that merely because I may desire that conclusion?"
Daemon did not answer immediately.
"I know I may be wrong," Rhaegar said calmly. "But doing nothing merely because one may be wrong is also a choice."
"You could investigate further."
"Until when?"
Daemon's eyes narrowed slightly.
Rhaegar continued.
"Not everything grants us sufficient time."
It was not wrong.
Winter did not wait for men to become certain.
Nor did war.
Nor famine.
Nor disease.
The reports a ruler received were never complete, and there were far more matters where one had to decide with inadequate information than matters where one could judge only after sufficient evidence had been gathered.
"If I judge wrongly, others die," Rhaegar said. "But if I know there is danger and do not act for lack of certainty, others may die then as well."
After a pause, he added, "A man who will become king cannot flee that responsibility, either."
Daemon said nothing.
Rhaegar did not believe in prophecy merely because he was intoxicated by the notion that he was special.
It was almost the opposite.
If some role had truly been entrusted to him, and he doubted it, missed it, and someone died as a result—he was the sort of man who thought he could not bear that responsibility.
A sense of responsibility was a virtue.
Which was why it could also be dangerous.
"I do not oppose preparing itself," Daemon said.
"Then what is the problem?"
"Preparation and obedience are different things."
Rhaegar waited silently.
"If winter seems likely to be long, one stores grain. If danger seems likely to come from the North, one strengthens the Wall and readies soldiers."
"Yes."
"But when prophecy begins deciding people's lives, the matter changes."
Daemon's voice lowered slightly.
"Whom one must marry."
The smile left Rhaegar's face.
"Who must die."
After a moment:
"Who must play a certain role, no matter what."
Daemon did not touch his cup.
"From that point, it is no longer preparing for the future."
Their eyes met.
"It is forcing the present to fit the future one has interpreted."
"Not every prophecy demands such choices."
"That is true."
Daemon conceded it at once.
"Which is why it is harder."
After thinking for a while, Daemon spoke again.
"Once, I heard an old tale from a merchant who used to visit Sea Dragon Point."
Rhaegar waited.
In a distant land, there was a king and queen.
A son was born to them.
An oracle declared that the child would one day kill his father and marry his mother.
The king and queen were afraid.
They abandoned the child.
But the child lived.
He grew beneath other parents.
And later, the child himself heard the same oracle.
He loved those whom he believed were his parents, so he left them to escape his fate.
On the road, he met his true father.
Neither knew who the other was.
They quarreled.
The son killed the father.
Then he went to the land where he had been born.
Not knowing she was his true mother, he married her.
Daemon stopped speaking.
Rhaegar was quiet for some time.
"Did they follow the prophecy?" Daemon asked. "Or did they defy it?"
"They tried to defy it."
"Yet it came to pass."
Rhaegar considered.
"So it did."
"What would have happened if the first king had done nothing?"
"We cannot know."
"And if the son had not left even after hearing the second oracle?"
"We cannot know that, either."
"Neither do I."
Daemon put down his cup.
"That is what is frightening."
Whether prophecy had shown the future.
Whether the actions of those who heard it had created the future.
Whether those actions had already been part of the future.
There was no way to know.
Rhaegar asked, "Then can one make no choice at all? If acting in belief of prophecy is part of it, and defying it is part of it as well, should we not simply do what we think right regardless of prophecy?"
Daemon was silent briefly.
Then he smiled.
"That is why Your Highness and I keep returning to the same place."
Rhaegar smiled faintly as well.
They were not clashing because they failed to understand one another.
Rather, they understood each other with considerable accuracy.
Rhaegar feared knowing of danger and failing to act.
Daemon feared that a man certain of an uncertain danger would force the people of the present into his vision of the future.
Both spoke of responsibility.
They simply meant different responsibilities.
Neither fear was ridiculous.
Had this been another history in which nothing changed, Rhaegar's life would have shown that problem with cruel clarity.
What he had thought when he offered a winter rose to the daughter of the North at Harrenhal.
What he believed when he vanished with Lyanna Stark.
How much love and prophecy, duty and desire, each had occupied in that choice could never be fully known unless those concerned spoke.
But motive and consequence were not the same.
Following one prince's choice, Brandon Stark could ride south.
Rickard Stark could follow his son.
Aerys Targaryen's madness could set it aflame.
And once the king demanded the lives of Eddard Stark and Robert Baratheon as well, the matter was no longer the tale of one man and one woman.
Swords would be drawn.
The realm would divide.
Rubies would scatter upon the waters of the Trident.
The gates of King's Landing would open.
Countless people would die without even knowing what the prophecy had been.
To lay all that responsibility upon Rhaegar alone would be a lie.
There was Aerys's madness and tyranny.
There were political grievances long accumulated.
There was Brandon's rashness.
There were the choices each house made.
History was rarely made by one person's hand alone.
But the fact that there was more than one cause did not mean a choice ceased to be one of them.
Nor was it anything but too easy to laugh at Rhaegar's fear as simple delusion.
In this world, the Long Night had truly existed.
The Others existed as well.
Dragons could be reborn.
Even the dead walking was not wholly impossible.
Reality itself betrayed human common sense too often to sweep gods, prophecies, and magic aside with a single word: superstition.
In the end, the difficult matter was not whether one believed or disbelieved.
It was how far an imperfect belief might be carried into action.
Daemon looked at his cup for a moment.
"I do not know what gods may exist."
Rhaegar watched him quietly.
"The old gods may watch us beyond the weirwoods. The Seven Who Are One may truly protect men."
After a pause:
"Perhaps there is something whose name we do not even know."
Daemon could not deny the existence of gods.
He had died once.
Then he had been born again.
In another body.
With another name.
In another world.
With the memories of his former life intact.
For such a man to claim that what humanity could not understand did not exist simply because it could not be seen would have been the more irrational position.
"But, Your Highness."
"Yes."
"Ants cannot understand us, either."
Rhaegar's brows rose slightly.
Daemon lightly tapped the edge of the table with one finger.
"We may leave food beside an anthill. We may lay a road, or crush it beneath our feet by accident."
To the ants, all would be events.
Food that seemed a divine blessing.
A road like a calamity dividing the world.
A home destroyed for reasons they could not know.
Yet to humans, these might be acts without any meaning at all.
"If gods truly are immortal," Daemon said, "who can assure us that the difference between beings who die after a few decades and them is smaller than the difference between humans and ants?"
Rhaegar did not answer.
"Perhaps a god truly has given prophecy."
Daemon did not deny the possibility.
"But the ears hearing those words are human."
The hands recording them were human.
The hands carrying them onward.
The eyes reading them centuries later.
The minds interpreting their meaning.
"I fear human interpretation more than prophecy itself."
"But we cannot refrain from interpreting it."
"No, we cannot."
Daemon admitted it immediately.
"Which is why it is difficult."
"Someone must judge in the end."
"Yes."
"Someone must choose."
"That is true as well."
Rhaegar asked, "Then what is the difference between us?"
Daemon thought for a moment.
"I do not think my judgment is the correct answer."
Rhaegar's expression shifted slightly.
"I only choose what I think best with the information and experience I possess at the time."
"And if you are wrong?"
"Then I must correct it."
The answer came quickly.
Rhaegar asked, "Can you abandon so easily what you believed was right?"
"What do you mean?"
"What you believed was right."
"It is not easy."
Daemon smiled slightly.
"There have not been many times I enjoyed confirming that a hypothesis I had built over months was wrong."
After a moment, he continued, "But if I am wrong, reality will not conform to my thinking merely because I stubbornly persist."
The evidence is inadequate.
It is too early to judge.
We must observe more.
Those had been conclusions he reached countless times in the laboratory of his former life.
They were not failures.
"Not knowing is an answer as well."
Rhaegar looked at him.
"For a scholar, perhaps."
Daemon's eyes narrowed.
"Is it for a king as well?"
This time, Daemon could not answer at once.
Rhaegar continued slowly.
"Suppose the army must march tomorrow."
"..."
"One report says supplies are sufficient. Another says they are lacking. There is no time to determine which is right."
Rhaegar lifted his hand from his cup.
"The king must still decide."
Daemon listened.
"Soldiers cannot accept the king's command as a provisional hypothesis."
That struck painfully.
Because it was true.
The one making a judgment could remember that the judgment was provisional.
But those receiving orders could not.
Once battle began, a commander could not tell soldiers that the decision remained unverified, so they should fight first and see what results followed.
Someone had to decide.
Someone had to stake their lives on that decision.
After a long silence, Daemon said, "That is why I understand that Your Highness cannot wait in every matter."
Rhaegar said, "Then are we not, in the end, not so different?"
"There is one difference."
"What is it?"
"Not forgetting that I may be wrong."
Daemon looked at Rhaegar.
"When giving an order, one may need to give it with certainty. But need one's mind be filled with certainty as well?"
When new facts emerged, he corrected himself.
When circumstances changed, he changed with them.
When a better answer appeared, he discarded the former conclusion.
To Daemon, that was what a decision was.
Rhaegar said, "You think prophecy should be treated in the same way."
"Yes."
Daemon did not hesitate.
"I think prophecy should be a guideline."
After a pause:
"It should not become the conclusion."
Rhaegar was silent for a long time.
Then he asked, "Where is that boundary?"
Daemon did not answer.
This time Rhaegar continued.
"We believed a warning that winter was coming and stored grain."
"Yes."
"Winter did not come."
Rhaegar's voice remained calm.
"Who bears responsibility for what we sacrificed to buy that grain?"
Daemon listened.
"We thought war would come and raised more soldiers, but nothing happened."
After a moment:
"Or we did not believe, and war truly came."
Their eyes met.
"Then people will die."
It was not wrong.
Rhaegar was not a man who believed in prophecy because he wished to rule the future.
At least, not now.
He was a man afraid that there was something he must do, and that he might miss it.
Conversely, Daemon feared that this very sense of responsibility might someday make a man unable to stop.
Their weaknesses were not far removed from their strengths.
Rhaegar could go too far because of his sense of responsibility.
Daemon could act too late because he doubted.
That difference was not the kind that would disappear in a few words.
"If the gods have truly given us warning," Rhaegar said, "is not recognizing that warning and acting upon it also our duty?"
Daemon's gaze paused briefly.
His own logic had been returned to him intact.
It was a good rebuttal.
"It may be."
Rhaegar seemed slightly surprised.
"You concede readily."
"Would it not be rather absurd for a man who has said his own view is not absolutely correct to become stubborn here?"
Rhaegar gave a small laugh.
Daemon followed with one of his own.
But neither changed his mind.
Rhaegar said, "It is not that I fail to understand your words."
"Yes."
"I even think they are right in considerable part."
Daemon's brows rose slightly.
"And yet your view remains unchanged."
"Yes."
He was resolute.
His voice did not rise.
Daemon asked, "Why?"
This time, Rhaegar could not answer immediately.
Ancient records.
Recurring dreams.
Fire.
Dragons.
The history of his house.
The day he was born.
A certain sensation he felt whenever he read and thought on all of it.
Separately, none was evidence.
Rhaegar knew that as well.
Which made it harder to explain in words.
After a long while, he said, "There are things difficult to explain."
Daemon looked at Rhaegar.
Ah.
From here, it was no longer solely a matter of logic.
That did not mean Rhaegar had abandoned thought.
After thinking, doubting, and examining countless times, what remained at the very bottom was this:
Belief.
Certainty.
Perhaps faith.
Daemon did not press further.
It was not something that could be broken by a few lines of logic.
And honestly, he was not certain it should be broken.
He himself could not wholly deny gods, while unable to prove their existence.
Silence settled over the room for a time.
Daemon watched the lamp.
Rhaegar was far better than he had been four years ago.
He doubted records.
He heard counterarguments.
He admitted the possibility that he might be wrong.
But knowing how to think and necessarily reaching the right conclusion were not the same thing.
The same was true of Daemon.
He believed he could change his mind at any time.
He believed he was wary of certainty.
Who could guarantee that this belief would not become another certainty?
What makes me any different?
It was a conclusion he disliked.
Which made it harder to ignore.
Daemon exhaled slowly.
"Your Highness."
"Yes."
"May I ask one favor?"
Rhaegar looked at him.
"Speak."
"I do not ask that you grant it now."
"Then when?"
Daemon thought for a moment.
He did not know the precise time.
He did not yet know what he would ask.
But through this evening's conversation, he had learned one thing.
It was impossible to persuade Rhaegar now.
And Daemon could not be certain he himself was right.
Then at least, someday—when Rhaegar himself encountered something that did not accord with his present beliefs, and came to feel that he, not another, must stop and think again—Daemon could leave behind one small reason to use then.
"In the future," Daemon said. "If you encounter reason to doubt what you now believe."
Rhaegar's eyes narrowed slightly.
"And if a day comes when, not because someone forces persuasion upon you but because you yourself truly feel you must reconsider."
After a pause:
"Will you grant me one request then?"
Rhaegar did not answer at once.
"Without even knowing what it is?"
"That is rather shameless of me."
A small smile appeared at Rhaegar's lips.
Daemon smiled as well.
"It is presumptuous to call it a request."
"Daemon," Rhaegar said gently, "after speaking of such things for several hours, are you only now concerned about presumption?"
Daemon closed his mouth for a moment.
That was true, too.
"Then... I will call it one wish."
"A wish."
"Yes."
"Without saying what it is?"
"In truth, I do not know yet either."
This time Rhaegar laughed a little louder.
"That is a remarkably unfair promise."
"If you refuse, I will have no complaint."
Rhaegar considered for a moment.
"I cannot promise to grant anything whatsoever."
Daemon nodded at once.
"Of course."
If the crown prince promised unconditionally to grant a request whose nature he did not know, that would be more worrying still.
"If it is something I cannot do, I will refuse."
"Yes."
"The same if it would harm the realm."
"Naturally."
Rhaegar looked at Daemon.
"But if such a day as you describe truly comes."
After a pause:
"I will grant one wish, as far as I am able."
Daemon considered those words.
There was no promise of anything.
No promise of certainty.
Only: as far as he was able.
That was enough.
"That is enough."
Rhaegar nodded.
Neither attached greater meaning to the promise.
Daemon did not yet know what he would ask.
Rhaegar did not believe a day would come when he truly doubted the conviction he now held.
Thus the promise made that night was no more than one small promise left at the end of a long conversation that had begun with ancient history and flowed through prophecy and gods, responsibility and choice.
At least, it was so for now.
The future was not fixed.
Daemon liked that fact.
Perhaps it was precisely that which Rhaegar feared.
Comments (0)
Please log in to leave a comment. Login or Register