Login Register

Chapter 31: What Remained After the Fire Went Out

Even after returning from the saltpeter fields to the manor, Daemon could not cool his head.


He made several circuits of the solar. He went to the window, returned to the desk, stopped before the hearth for a while, then looked outside again, but the words the free folk man had slowly brought forth in broken Common Tongue would not leave his mind.


The Long Night.


Men who walked despite being dead.


Something whiter and colder than snow.


Blue eyes.


The Others.


And glass made by flame.


What he had heard today was merely one man’s tale. Nor was it even the testimony of someone who had seen it himself. He had heard it from his parents, who had heard it from their grandparents, a tale perhaps passed down from generations even further removed.


It was pathetic evidence.


The problem was that Daemon had told him nothing beforehand.


He had not mentioned blue eyes. He had not spoken of dead men moving, nor had he led the man toward the notion of white beings. He had only asked the old free folk man who had come down from beyond the Wall to tell him old stories, and from that man’s mouth had spilled fragments far too similar to what Daemon had seen in his vision.


Daemon pressed his fingers hard against his temple.


"One."


One sample.


If he seized on this and reached a conclusion, he would not be a researcher. He would be a fortune-teller.


So he would verify it further.


He would hear from others and read records preserved in other regions. If the same things appeared in tales that could not easily have influenced one another, then it would become somewhat harder to dismiss them with a single word: coincidence.


Daemon called for the servant outside the door.


"Please fetch Maester Luwin."


"Yes, Lord Seadrake."


Not long afterward, the door opened.


"You called for me?"


"I need to borrow some books."


Luwin’s expression eased ever so slightly.


Recently, when Daemon sought him out, it was usually because a new problem had arisen in the workshop, because he intended to tear apart and rebuild some other corner of the domain, or because he had seized upon a custom that had continued perfectly well and asked why it had to be done that way at all.


Books were a peaceful request by comparison.


"What sort of books?"


"From the Dawn Age through the Age of Heroes. Especially the Long Night, Brandon the Builder, Winterfell, and the Wall. It would be good to have structures in the south named for Brandon as well. And records from Essos with stories resembling the Long Night."


Luwin considered it briefly.


"That is quite a broad scope."


"Which is why I need a great many of them."


"What are you trying to verify?"


Daemon answered with complete seriousness.


"Just how much bullshit people in the old days made up."


"..."


"And whether people who could not possibly have met were making up exactly the same bullshit in the same places."


The look in Luwin’s eyes changed a little.


"You intend to compare traditions?"


"Yes. If possible, ones copied at different times. I want to see whether someone later reorganized them, and how they changed from region to region."


"You are beginning with a considerable degree of suspicion."


"They write that something happened twelve thousand years ago, but the man who wrote it down must have lived far later than that, mustn’t he?"


Daemon shrugged.


"Isn’t scholarship about doubting what other people say before anything else?"


The corner of Luwin’s mouth moved faintly.


"A somewhat extreme definition, but very well."


He left.


Then he returned carrying far more books than Daemon had expected.


It did not end with one trip. On the second, he carried books in both hands. On the third, he had enlisted a servant as well.


Daemon blinked as he watched the pile of books rise like a tower at one end of his desk.


"...There are this many?"


"You asked me to bring as many as possible."


"I did, but still."


"For the Dawn Age and the Age of Heroes, there are far more traditions compiled later than reliable contemporary records. Even the stories concerning the same person differ from region to region."


Daemon’s eyes brightened slightly.


"Then that is even better."


"Better?"


"If they differ, I can compare them."


Luwin watched him for a moment, then shook his head.


"Call if you need anything."


"All right."


The door shut.


Daemon pulled paper and ink toward him and rolled up his sleeves.


"Good."


He opened the first book.


"Let us see who spun the most convincing bullshit."


The trouble began immediately.


Chronology.


The Dawn Age.


Twelve thousand years ago.


Other records claimed it was older still.


Daemon stared at that number for some time.


"That is a grand claim."


This was a world where even now it was not uncommon for men to fail to reconcile a tax record from ten years earlier, yet someone living thousands of years after an age with no proper written records had written it down and insisted it was exactly twelve thousand years ago.


He was right not to trust the number itself, at least.


But neither could he say the event had never happened merely because it was ancient.


He recalled ancient ruins he had seen somewhere in his previous life. Their names and details were hazy, but he remembered that humans from an age thought to have had neither proper states nor cities had nevertheless already gathered in great numbers and raised enormous stone structures.


People of old were not automatically stupid.


The records were simply a fucking mess.


Daemon wrote a brief note.


『Do not trust dates at first. Examine events separately.』


"That will do for now."


He turned the page.


Then his hand stopped at an old description of the seasons.


At first, he paid it no mind.


It said seeds were sown in spring, crops grew in summer, harvest came in autumn, and winter was a time of rest.


A later copyist might have altered it conveniently so people of his own age could understand.


Yet traditions from another region set sowing time by the height at which the sun rose and the length of the day.


Another record said they prepared for harvest around the time a particular star began to appear.


Daemon narrowed his eyes.


"...Wait."


In present-day Westeros, such things were impossible.


No one knew whether spring would last months or years. The same was true of summer, and winter was worse.


Yet the people in ancient records treated the seasons as though they returned in a fixed order.


Of course, later hands might have meddled with them.


So he wrote that down beside it first.


But after turning several more pages, similar phrases kept recurring.


Daemon made a small circle in the corner of the book.


"That is rather suspicious."


For now, that was all.


Mark the strange parts.


Reach conclusions later.


Magic was far more troublesome.


In his previous life, tales like these would have been dismissed as one of three things: myths, legends, or exaggerations. Here, they touched reality too often.


Holding his pen, Daemon touched the skin around his right eye.


The eye that had turned violet after his vision.


And then there was Aspera.


"...Fuck."


He could not dismiss magic from the outset.


That irritated him most of all.


If, in the name of thinking scientifically, he automatically treated a phenomenon that truly existed as a lie, that would be the unscientific thing to do.


Daemon wrote on the page.


『Doubt exaggeration. Do not discard the possibility of existence itself.』


After pondering for a moment, he wrote beneath it.


"My daughter is a dragon, though?"


He stared at it for a while.


"A perfect counterexample."


Who could refute it?


Dragons were real.


Once he reached the Long Night, the speed at which he turned pages noticeably slowed.


The details differed by region.


In some places, a hero fought the darkness. In others, the sun hid its face. Elsewhere, rather than monsters, the heart of the tale was endless cold and hunger itself.


But when he stripped away the details, an eerily identical framework remained.


Darkness that lasted far too long.


An unnatural winter.


A calamity great enough to bring down people and civilization.


And light, returned at last.


Daemon recalled the many flood myths he had encountered in his former life.


Similar stories arising in many civilizations did not necessarily mean there had been a single flood that covered the entire world. Different regions might have suffered different disasters; a tale could have traveled far; distinct events might have mingled over thousands of years.


But the reverse was true as well.


When memories across such a broad expanse preserved similar abnormal events, insisting nothing had happened also required an explanation.


Daemon wrote briefly.


『The Long Night likely has its basis in a real catastrophe. Details are unreliable.』


That was as far as he would go for now.


And then.


Brandon the Builder.


Daemon lingered over this man’s name the longest.


"Why the hell does this fellow appear everywhere?"


Among the places Brandon was said to have helped build, the southernmost to catch his eye was Storm’s End.


According to tradition, a young Brandon advised Durran Godsgrief and helped him build the final castle.


Daemon spent a long time reading the description of Storm’s End’s structure.


An enormous curved curtain wall.


And a single great round tower.


In truth, its outward form was exceedingly simple.


"...Simple, isn’t it?"


There were no complicated clusters of towers.


Instead of meeting the savage storms and sea winds head-on, it had a curved outer wall that seemed to let them flow around it, tremendous thickness, and a structure that concentrated its inner functions in one colossal tower.


Simple.


But absurdly strong.


Daemon moved his gaze northward.


Ancient keeps and structures associated with Brandon’s name.


Their exact dates were unclear, and there was no reason to believe one man truly built them all.


Yet.


They seemed to grow more advanced as one went north.


In the south, functional and relatively simple stone defenses.


Farther north, larger and more complex strongholds.


At the end of them, Winterfell.


And then.


The Wall.


Daemon’s hand stopped.


"...Wait."


What if technology had advanced over time?


Or.


What if stronger defenses had been needed the farther north one went?


Both were possible.


Moreover, among the things bearing Brandon’s name, those that stood out were defenses: walls and strongholds.


Daemon stared down at the map for a long while.


"Rather than an architect..."


For a moment.


"Wasn’t he a man who built buildings while fighting a war?"


Once he said it, the entire picture changed.


The Long Night.


People are driven south.


The Others and the dead follow them.


No one knows exactly how far they were pushed.


Then, at some point, they strike back.


They reclaim some of the land they lost.


They establish a stronghold.


They advance again.


A new stronghold.


As the fighting drags on, their skill accumulates.


The farther north they go, the stronger the enemy becomes, and the sturdier, more complex defenses they need.


Then Winterfell.


Farther north still.


The Wall.


Daemon’s pen halted.


"...Surely not."


What if the Wall was not the first line of defense?


What if it had been raised to seal off the final line secured after humanity and its allies reclaimed land from south to north?


Then Winterfell was not directly behind the front line.


It lay somewhat farther south.


Men could be gathered there.


Grain could be stored there.


Its hot springs made it fit to endure a long winter.


It was well situated to send forces in many directions across the North.


Daemon drew a circle around Winterfell.


"Rear base."


Once he thought of it that way, House Stark’s words looked entirely different.


Winter is coming.


Daemon stared at those words for a long time.


For northerners, the fact that winter came was far too obvious.


There was no need to repeat as a family motto, generation after generation, that snow would fall and the cold would come.


Of course, it might mean only that they must always prepare for the coming winter.


It was the simplest explanation, and therefore the one that ought to be considered first.


But.


What if the Long Night had truly happened?


Then those words might mean something else.


Not an ordinary winter.


The winter that had nearly ended the world once.


And would someday come again.


So do not forget.


Prepare.


"...I am getting ahead of myself."


Daemon put down his pen.


He was building speculation upon speculation.


That was the most dangerous thing.


He had seen it countless times in his previous life.


Researchers who fell in love with their conclusion.


If experimental values differed from what they wanted, they changed the conditions. If they still did not fit, they called them outliers and removed them. In the end, when only numbers that suited their own notions remained, they declared their hypothesis proven.


"Bullshit."


Daemon rubbed his face.


At this point, continuing alone was more dangerous.


He needed someone who did not like his ideas.


More precisely.


Someone who would dislike his hypothesis.


Outside, it was already dark.


"...Maester Luwin must be asleep."


His conscience pricked him a little.


Daemon looked at the bell.


"I am sorry."


He apologized before even calling for the man.


Then he rang the bell.


*


Luwin had indeed been asleep.


He had come properly dressed, but one side of his hair was slightly flattened.


Seeing it made Daemon feel a little guilty.


Truly.


Only a little.


"Maester."


"Yes, Lord Seadrake."


"First, I am sorry."


Luwin looked at him for a moment.


"Since you are apologizing first, you do realize that it is very late."


"I do."


"Could this not have waited until morning?"


"I do not think I should keep thinking about it alone."


Luwin’s gaze went to the desk.


Books.


A map.


Notes.


Marks where lines had been drawn and erased.


And the sentence written in large letters beside the Wall.


『What in the hell is this wall supposed to do?』


Luwin was silent for a moment.


Daemon pulled out the chair opposite him.


"Have a seat."


"My lord."


"I am about to say some rather strange things."


"I have already expected as much."


"They may be stranger than you think."


With a sigh, Luwin sat down.


"Speak, then."


"But do not call me mad halfway through."


"I will judge after I hear what you have to say."


"You are coldhearted."


Daemon began by explaining what he had seen.


Ancient dates were difficult to trust.


But the fact that their dates were inaccurate did not mean the events themselves had never existed.


Within Dawn Age traditions were traces suggesting that seasons had turned far more regularly than they did now.


The Long Night remained in different regions with a similar core.


And when the structures left under the name Brandon the Builder were laid upon a map, their scale and complexity appeared to increase from Storm’s End northward.


As expected, Luwin immediately cut in.


"Lord Seadrake. First, most traditions concerning Brandon the Builder have uncertain dates."


"I know."


"There is no evidence that the young Brandon who helped build Storm’s End and the Brandon said to have built the Wall were the same man."


"I know that too."


"Then it is dangerous to view this as technology advancing from south to north."


Daemon thought for a moment.


Then he drew a large question mark beside the line he had made.


"So it is only this much, for now."


"Adding a question mark does not create evidence."


"I know."


Daemon smiled.


"That is why I woke you."


Luwin stared at the map a while longer.


Daemon said, "Still, it is strange, is it not?"


"What is?"


"Storm’s End, which Brandon supposedly helped build, is simple in shape."


Daemon pointed at the drawing with his hand.


"One large wall. One large tower. The size and defensive strength are insane, of course, but the structure itself is simple."


Then his finger moved north.


"But by the time one reaches Winterfell, the castle itself has become far larger and more complex."


Finally.


"And the Wall has nothing that can even be compared to it."


An immense wall of ice crossed the northern reaches of the continent.


And, if the traditions were true, it had been raised with giants and even the children of the forest.


Luwin considered it briefly.


"It may be technological development over time."


"It could be."


"Later generations may also have placed older structures under Brandon’s name."


"That too."


Daemon immediately conceded the point.


"But what if they emerged during one war, the Long Night?"


From there, the tale changed.


At first, a simple fort.


They fight.


It falls.


They survive.


They learn.


Next time, they build better.


The enemy grows stronger.


So do the defenses.


The farther north they advance, the closer the war draws to its end.


And ultimately.


The Wall.


Luwin said nothing for quite a long time.


Daemon asked, "Am I very mad?"


"There are far too many assumptions."


"I know."


"But."


Luwin looked at the Wall.


"If we first accept the tradition that the Wall was raised after the Long Night, then interpreting it not as the first line of defense but as the final defense built after the war ended does not, in itself, contradict the traditions."


Daemon’s eyes brightened.


"Right?"


"Not contradicting something and being correct are different matters."


"I know. I understand the difference."


"Then why are you so pleased?"


"There is no proof it is wrong yet."


Luwin sighed.


"You are excessively fond of the space between possibility and fact."


"That is where all the interesting things are."


The matter of Winterfell followed naturally.


If there had truly been a counteroffensive, Winterfell might be seen as a large base set somewhat behind the front line.


After the war, its military importance may have merged with royal power, after which it became the Stark seat.


Of course, the reverse could also be true.


Winterfell might have grown because the Starks were kings.


Daemon did not settle on either.


But.


Winter is coming.


Those words continued to trouble him.


"If the Long Night truly happened, this might not simply be about the weather."


Luwin thought for a moment.


"A warning."


"Yes."


Daemon nodded.


"Do not forget."


A moment passed.


"Because it may come again."


And then.


The free folk.


Daemon recalled what he had heard that day.


Free folk.


Kneelers.


"The more I consider this, the stranger it is."


Luwin asked, "In what way?"


"They do not call us southerners."


It was not a regional name.


Not the name of a kingdom.


Not the name of a people.


『Kneelers.』


Daemon tapped the expression with a finger.


"It is a political term."


You knelt to a king.


You submitted to a lord.


You acknowledged another’s rule.


And in contrast, the people beyond the Wall called themselves free folk.


Not free because they lived in the north.


Free because they had knelt to no one.


"Most people would simply think it became that way because there are no kings over there, while there are kings in the south."


"It is the simplest explanation."


"I know."


Daemon nodded.


"But what if we reverse the order?"


Luwin’s gaze deepened slightly.


"Not that they became free folk because there were no kings."


Daemon pointed at the Wall.


"What if men who did not want to submit to kings remained in the north and became free folk?"


The Long Night ends.


People survived.


Then comes rebuilding.


They must rebuild fallen villages.


They must gather grain.


They must maintain soldiers.


They must build castles, in case something happens again.


In such an age, a strong system of command is needed.


Whether king.


Or chieftain.


Something stands above the people.


It gives orders.


It collects taxes.


It summons soldiers.


"After enduring a war like the Long Night, royal power might actually grow stronger."


"That is entirely possible."


"But fighting together does not mean everyone has to enter that system."


Daemon spread his hands as though imitating someone.


"Yes, we fought together."


"So?"


"I did not fight to become your underling."


The corner of Luwin’s mouth moved slightly.


"A king?"


Daemon shook his head.


"No."


"Taxes?"


Again.


"No."


"Kneel to a lord?"


His expression soured before he spoke.


"Fuck off."


"Your wording is rather extreme, but."


"You understand the feeling."


"Yes."


Some such people may have lived north of the Wall from the beginning.


Some might have advanced north during the counterattack and simply stayed there.


Others may have gone north again because they did not wish to enter the new order of kings and lords.


And.


Daemon paused a little.


"There might have been those who pursued them to the end."


"The Others?"


"Yes."


If the Long Night had truly been so terrible.


People died.


But that was not the end.


The dead rose again and killed the living.


Families died.


Villages vanished.


Friends died.


Even children died.


After enduring such things, the enemy retreats north.


When the Wall is raised and men say that this is enough, would everyone truly stop there?


"Someone might have pursued them to the end, determined to wipe out every last one."


Luwin listened quietly.


"For vengeance."


"Or to make certain they could never come south again."


"That too."


Daemon looked north.


Thus, different people remained beyond the Wall.


Those who had lived in the north from the first.


Those who rejected the new royal power.


Those who had gone farther north in pursuit or vengeance.


As years passed, the distinctions vanished.


Tribes split apart.


Joined again.


Intermarried.


Fought.


Thousands of years passed.


The reason was forgotten.


But.


The words remained.


We are free folk.


You are kneelers.


Daemon stared at the two phrases for a long while.


"This."


"Yes."


"If it is true, the identity of the free folk itself may not simply be a way of life."


A pause.


"It may be a fossil of the political division that emerged after the Long Night."


Luwin did not readily agree.


"It is possible, but for now it is a rather far-reaching inference."


"I know."


Daemon conceded it at once.


"That is why we need to examine their songs and stories before the books."


How they remembered the Wall.


How far back traditions of refusing to kneel to kings remained.


Whether they had tales of those who went farther north.


And.


"If the free folk truly are descendants of people who fought in the Long Night."


Daemon spoke.


"They may have preserved forms older than those in the south."


Luwin narrowed his eyes slightly.


Daemon indicated the pile of books.


"We wrote things down."


Writing preserved them.


But.


Maesters organized them.


When dynasties changed, they interpreted them anew.


When a new faith arrived, old myths might be altered to fit its frame.


The free folk, in contrast, had scarcely any such process of organization.


"Naturally, oral traditions must have been horribly distorted."


"Undoubtedly."


"But distorted in another way."


Daemon gave a faint laugh.


"If we compare sources that have been damaged differently, perhaps intact fragments remain between them."


At that, Luwin slowly nodded.


"That would certainly be worth studying."


The corners of Daemon’s mouth lifted.


"You are beginning to find it interesting too, aren’t you?"


"I would say it is academically intriguing."


"That means interesting."


"They are different."


"They are the same."


Then Daemon’s finger stopped on the Wall.


In the end, they could no longer avoid speaking of magic.


"But, Maester."


"Yes."


"If we are to keep discussing the Wall, I think we need to sort out magic first."


This time, Luwin did not urge him on.


Daemon stared at the map for a long while.


"Doesn’t magic seem to favor certain places?"


"What do you mean?"


Daemon moved his finger east.


"The Rhoynar."


The people of the Rhoyne.


In tradition, they were deeply connected to water.


They commanded the river itself.


Raised water.


There were even tales that they fought the Valyrians with that power.


Daemon’s finger moved farther east.


"Asshai."


There, stories of shadow magic and bizarre sorcery were particularly abundant.


West again.


Then north.


"Here, greenseers and wargs."


Weirwoods.


The children of the forest.


Tales of borrowing the eyes of beasts, and seeing distant things through trees.


When regions changed, so did the forms of magic.


"Water in the Rhoyne."


Daemon said, "Shadows around Asshai."


He pointed north.


"Here, communion with weirwoods and beasts."


And then.


Valyria.


"There, dragons, fire, and blood."


Daemon twisted his lips as he looked at the map.


"The regional character is too strong."


Luwin looked down at the map as well.


"It could simply be that each culture developed myths and rites suited to its environment."


"That is true."


"But you believe the nature of the actual power itself varied by region."


"I am considering the possibility."


Daemon slowly connected several points with his finger.


"Suppose there are paths where a certain force gathers, whether beneath the earth or elsewhere."


A brief pause.


"Ley lines."


Luwin spoke.


Daemon looked up.


"Yes. Let us call them that for the moment."


Just as rivers flowed along riverbeds, if magic did not arise equally anywhere and everywhere but waxed and waned according to particular lands and paths, it would explain to some degree why different forms of magic developed in each region.


Daemon looked at the Wall.


"Then this wall, too."


"You mean it may be connected to that flow."


"Yes."


After a moment, Daemon looked at Luwin.


"But, Maester."


"What is it?"


"I thought the Citadel disliked magic very much."


One of Luwin’s brows shifted slightly.


"Why do you bring that up suddenly?"


"Since earlier."


Daemon sounded puzzled.


"I keep going on about ley lines and the Wall’s magic, yet instead of telling me to stop speaking nonsense, you only ask whether I have evidence."


"Your wording is a little."


"Anyway."


"It is true that many at the Citadel regard magic unfavorably."


Luwin paused.


Then he tugged the chain around his neck with one hand.


Amid its many metal links, a dark link that did not shine brightly even in candlelight appeared.


Fine ripples patterned its surface.


Daemon’s gaze stopped.


"...Valyrian steel?"


"Yes."


Luwin raised the link with a finger.


"It is the link given to a maester who has studied the higher mysteries."


Daemon’s eyes widened.


"You studied magic?"


"For longer than you may think."


"Why did you never say so?"


"You never asked."


"No, but."


Stunned, Daemon stared at the chain.


"Then have you cast spells too?"


Luwin’s expression became strange.


"Any student of the mysteries wishes to test such things at least once."


"Did it work?"


"No."


"Ah."


For some reason, Daemon was disappointed.


Luwin slowly let the Valyrian steel link fall back into place.


"I too do not like covering every unexplained event with the single word magic."


"Neither do I."


"But failing to understand something is different from it never having existed."


Luwin’s fingertips touched the Valyrian steel again.


"We possess this metal."


It did not rust after hundreds of years.


It was lighter and stronger than ordinary steel.


Its edge lasted longer too.


Yet.


No one could make it anew from the beginning now.


"The fact that we have lost its method of manufacture does not mean it does not exist."


Daemon’s face grew slightly more serious.


"You see magic the same way?"


"It is one possibility."


Luwin nodded.


"There may once have been principles and techniques people truly understood and used, but the knowledge and people needed to pass them on vanished, leaving us now to see only their results."


Daemon watched him for a while.


"Lost technology."


"If phrasing it so makes it easier for you to understand."


The corner of Daemon’s mouth rose.


"Now that I see it, you are very much to my taste."


"I will take that as praise."


"I thought everyone at the Citadel scoffed whenever magic was mentioned."


"I will not take that part as praise."


Daemon gave a small laugh.


Luwin returned his attention to the map.


"And."


"Yes?"


"Your account contains too many assumptions."


"I know."


"Even so."


Luwin slowly surveyed the Wall, the North, and the eastern lands.


"Considering both the concentration of traditions concerning different forms of magic in different regions, and the fact that the Wall itself is plainly unlike an ordinary fortification."


He paused.


"I believe it is a theory worth investigating."


Daemon’s face lit up.


"Right?"


"I said a theory."


"That is enough for me."


"Do not mistake it for fact."


"You do keep saying that."


"Because you keep trying to skip past it."


"...All right, I understand."


Daemon looked at the Wall again.


"Then what if."


If magic moved along a flow like ley lines.


And the Wall was a structure connected to that flow.


"Could it not be something like a dam?"


Luwin lifted his head.


"A dam."


"Something that blocks water."


"I know what a dam is."


"If magic flows too."


Daemon’s finger moved along the Wall.


"It might block something in the north."


"Weaken it."


"Divert it elsewhere."


Luwin considered it.


"Or contain in the north the very power used by the beings hostile during the Long Night."


Daemon’s head snapped up.


"That."


A subtle regret passed across Luwin’s face.


"It appears I have improved your hypothesis."


"You are really good at this."


"I regret it somewhat."


"Too late now."


But as he considered ley lines, Valyria naturally came to mind.


Daemon’s finger moved to the eastern part of the continent.


"Valyria."


Luwin looked there as well.


"Do you believe it was a center of magic?"


"At the least, it must have been extraordinarily powerful."


Dragons.


Blood magic.


Valyrian steel, whose manufacture was now lost.


Dragonlord families.


And.


The Fourteen Flames.


The Valyrian Freehold had been built atop a vast volcanic region.


Then, one day.


The Doom.


Volcanoes erupted.


The earth split.


The sea rushed in.


Cities, dragons, and dragonlords vanished.


The peninsula itself was torn apart.


Daemon tapped the account in the book with a finger.


"Even one enormous volcanic eruption does not only fuck up the immediate area."


One of Luwin’s brows twitched.


"Please refine your phrasing somewhat."


"It does not only devastate the immediate area."


Daemon amended his words.


Knowledge from his former life returned to him.


A massive eruption.


Ash and other matter entering the upper atmosphere.


Less sunlight.


Falling temperatures.


Crop failures.


Famine.


"Of course, there are fourteen of them, but we cannot simply calculate it as one large volcano times fourteen."


The scales of eruption differed.


So did their forms.


No one knew whether they erupted at exactly the same time.


But.


It had been enough to split apart the Valyrian peninsula itself.


"At that scale, I would expect even a geological disaster alone to have left larger marks on the surrounding world."


The world had plainly been in chaos after Valyria’s fall.


The Freehold vanished.


Colonies and cities became independent.


Wars broke out.


Slaves rebelled.


The Dothraki swept in.


But most of that could be explained by the sudden disappearance of a superpower.


What Daemon found strange was something else.


"The traces in the climate are weaker than I would expect."


"The records may simply be insufficient."


"They may be."


"Nor is there any guarantee that all fourteen flames caused massive eruptions."


"That too."


Daemon conceded immediately.


"But."


The Valyrians had lived beside those volcanoes for thousands of years.


Had they simply endured them?


They raised dragons.


Dug deep mines.


Studied blood magic.


Created technology so advanced that it could not now be reproduced.


"I do not think those people simply treated the Fourteen Flames as hot mountains."


Luwin listened in silence.


"Whether they used their heat."


"Or drew magical power from them."


"Or suppressed eruptions."


Daemon’s finger passed over the Fourteen Flames.


"Or linked several volcanoes and cities into a single magical system."


Then that system collapsed.


It was not merely that several volcanoes erupted.


The very landform of the Valyrian peninsula was torn apart.


Daemon’s expression grew more serious.


"If ley lines truly exist."


Luwin’s gaze lowered to the map.


"Then the Doom of Valyria damaged that very flow."


"Yes."


Daemon nodded slowly.


A vast center of magic.


A network maintained for thousands of years.


Cities and facilities built upon it.


Then one day.


A disaster great enough to split the peninsula struck.


Like severed wires.


Daemon said, "The paths along which magic flowed might have been torn apart everywhere."


Luwin did not answer easily.


"It would be difficult to prove."


"Naturally."


"But if we connect it to the regional magic you mentioned before."


Luwin chose his words more carefully.


"The hypothesis that the Doom of Valyria affected not merely the destruction of one civilization, but the magical environment of a far broader region, can stand."


Daemon looked at him.


"Maester."


"What is it?"


"I think you have started saying more dangerous things than I have."


"Was that not why you woke me in the middle of the night?"


"It was."


Daemon immediately admitted it.


And then.


Dragons.


When he reached that thought, something else troubled him.


Valyria was gone.


But dragons had not vanished.


The Targaryens of Dragonstone survived.


Balerion lived for a long time after the Doom as well.


New dragons were born afterward.


Eggs hatched.


Targaryen children were given eggs in their cradles, and some truly gained dragons.


Until just before the Dance of the Dragons, the number of living dragons had once again become considerable.


"So."


Daemon spoke slowly.


"Magic itself may have weakened greatly when Valyria fell."


A pause.


"But perhaps the dragons that remained somehow held it together?"


Luwin narrowed his eyes.


"Held it together."


"A catalyst."


Daemon searched for an appropriate word.


"Not creating new power that was not there before."


He turned his fingers.


"Helping the remaining power function properly."


"You mean dragons played that role."


"A possibility."


Daemon immediately raised a hand.


"The immense center that was Valyria vanished."


But.


Dragons remained.


While those dragons lived, faded magic did not entirely break off.


New dragons were born as well.


And then.


The Dance of the Dragons.


Daemon’s hand stopped atop the book.


Dragons killed dragons.


Adults.


Young dragons.


Many of them vanished in a short time.


"What if the catalysts were smashed all at once there?"


Luwin listened without speaking.


The remaining magic weakens further.


Then.


Hatching dragons becomes harder.


Fewer new dragons are born.


The catalysts diminish further.


Magic weakens further.


A vicious cycle.


Daemon drew a circle with his finger.


"There are fewer dragons, so magic weakens."


Then again.


"Magic weakens, so fewer dragons are born."


And then.


The last dragon.


Daemon recalled the record.


Small.


Misshapen.


A dragon that had failed to grow properly.


"That last dragon, too."


His voice lowered a little.


"What if it was not simply a problem of breeding or inheritance?"


A moment.


"What if so little magic remained that it was born that way because there was not enough even for it to hatch and grow?"


Luwin’s expression grew serious as well.


"Then the death of the last dragon becomes both cause and result."


Daemon’s eyes shone.


"Exactly."


Dragons vanished, so magic weakened.


Magic weakened, so dragons vanished.


The two dragged one another down.


Until, in the end.


They broke.


Daemon glanced at the family tree for a moment before speaking.


"And it is awkward to explain this by bloodline alone."


Luwin’s expression became faintly wary.


Daemon immediately said, "I am not questioning the royal line’s legitimacy."


"I have not said anything yet."


"Your face does not look pleased."


Daemon tapped the genealogy with his finger.


"If the reason dragons stopped being born was simply that the blood of dragonlords disappeared."


A pause.


"Then it means the entire royal family was cuckolded collectively for several generations after the Dance of the Dragons."


Silence.


The expression left Luwin’s face.


Daemon, having said it too naturally, stopped a beat later.


"..."


"..."


"No."


Daemon cleared his throat.


"I mean that is why it cannot be the explanation."


Luwin spoke very slowly.


"I recommend that you do not use that expression again."


"It is only the two of us."


"It must not be used even when it is only the two of us."


"Understood."


Daemon raised his hands.


But the logic remained.


People remained.


Targaryen blood remained.


Dragon eggs remained.


Kings attempted all manner of methods to restore dragons.


Yet hatching ceased.


Then it might be more natural to believe that bloodline and eggs alone lacked some necessary condition.


That condition was magic.


And then Daemon’s gaze returned to the Wall.


"Then."


Luwin followed his gaze.


"What of the Wall?"


A massive construction raised thousands of years ago, in an age when magic may have been much stronger.


A structure said to have involved even the children of the forest.


If it was not merely a wall of ice but a device with some magical function.


If the Doom of Valyria damaged the whole network of ley lines.


And magic weakened further as dragons, the catalysts, vanished.


There was no reason for the Wall to remain sound.


"It looks sound on the outside."


Daemon said.


The ice remained.


Its height remained the same.


The Night’s Watch still walked atop it.


So no one found it strange.


"But."


Daemon’s voice sank.


"What if its original function is completely fucked?"


This time, Luwin did not remark upon the phrasing.


"Suppose it required one hundred measures of magic for the Wall’s magical function when it was first built."


Daemon drew numbers in the air with a finger.


"But only ten measures of magic remain in the world now."


The ice might still stand.


There was stone and earth too.


Men maintained it.


The physical wall remained.


But.


Its function of stopping the Others.


Its function of stopping the dead from crossing.


Its function of blocking the power of the north.


What of those invisible parts?


"Who verifies them?"


Luwin could not answer.


Daemon pressed a fingertip against the Wall.


"A wall standing there."


A pause.


"And a wall functioning are different things."


This time, there was no joke.


The words remained in the room for a long while.


And then.


At that moment.


Daemon realized something.


Until now, he had stood outside all the evidence.


He had read books.


Compared traditions.


Built hypotheses.


He had been the observer.


But.


He was not.


The most unexplained phenomenon here was not the Others.


Not the Wall.


Not magic.


It was himself, Daemon.


I.


Died.


In South Korea.


He had been struck by a car and died.


Then.


He had been born again here.


With all his memories intact.


A dragon?


A warg?


A greenseer?


Magic?


At least this world bore traces that such things had always existed within it.


But what about him?


A man from another world who had died, opening his eyes in an infant’s body.


Did that make any more sense?


...I am stranger than a dragon.


Daemon looked down at his hands.


Then an old memory surfaced.


Immediately after he was born.


A tiny body.


He could not even speak.


His mind had been sound, but he could not properly move even one finger.


And then.


A dark red dragon egg.


When someone carried that egg away, anxiety abruptly seized him so fiercely it felt as though he could not breathe.


It was not the feeling that he wanted it.


It was the sense that they must not be separated.


The farther the egg moved away, the more he cried.


When it came near again, he calmed as though it were a lie.


At the time, he thought an infant’s body was simply reacting as it pleased.


Later, he dismissed it as a consequence of Valyrian blood.


But.


What if his hypothesis was right?


Valyria fell.


The ley lines were damaged.


Magic faded.


Even dragons, the catalysts, vanished one by one.


Eventually, dragons stopped hatching.


And yet.


He was born.


By an inexplicable means.


A consciousness from an entirely different world entered a body with dragonlord blood.


What if.


Daemon’s fingertips stiffened slightly.


What if his very existence was something like the role dragons had played?


Not something that created magic anew.


A catalyst that allowed the faint magic left behind to connect again.


Surely not.


He hated that thought.


But once it had arisen, he had to follow it to the end.


When he was born, he responded to Aspera’s egg.


From the beginning.


And he had grown.


One year old.


Five.


Ten.


Fourteen.


Dragons, too, grew larger and stronger as they aged.


Then.


Me too?


At first, he had been too weak as a catalyst.


So the egg had merely responded.


In a state where he could not tell whether it was alive or dead.


But as Daemon grew.


His body grew larger.


His body bearing Valyrian blood matured.


And something within it grew stronger too.


Then, at some point.


Enough to awaken a dragon egg.


What if it became enough?


Daemon’s heart gave one heavy beat.


Fourteen years.


Aspera.


The red comet.


The vision.


Violet eyes.


And then.


Hatching.


What if I, between magic and dragons, replaced the catalyst that had vanished?


He did not know exactly why.


Whether because of his reincarnated soul.


Because of dragonlord blood.


Because the two had joined.


Or for some entirely different reason.


He knew nothing.


But if Daemon had grown stronger as a catalyst with age, and Aspera awakened at the end of it.


What am I, some fucking magical Wi-Fi router?


Ordinarily, he would have laughed.


Now.


He could not laugh.


Because.


The return of a catalyst did not mean only dragons would benefit.


If all faded magic regained strength.


It would not only be things like the water magic of the Rhoynar that returned.


It would not only be greenseers and wargs that grew stronger.


It would not only be shadow magic that returned.


And then Daemon’s gaze slowly turned north.


The Wall.


Beyond it.


Blue eyes.


...Fuck.


If magic grew stronger, would the Others not grow stronger too?


The moment the thought arose, the vision returned vividly.


The Wall crumbled.


The enormous ice wall split apart.


And beyond it.


A thing with blue eyes stared straight at him.


A chill ran down Daemon’s spine.


This was something he could not tell Luwin.


That he had been reincarnated.


That Aspera existed.


That he had been bound to her egg from birth.


The vision.


All of it.


Therefore, he had to judge using only evidence he could bring into the open.


Daemon slowly exhaled.


Luwin looked at him.


"Lord Seadrake?"


"Yes."


"You do not look well."


"My thoughts went rather far."


That was not a lie.


They had gone far too far indeed.


Daemon gathered the scattered papers one by one.


The Long Night.


Brandon.


Storm’s End.


Winterfell.


Stark.


The free folk.


The Wall.


Irregular seasons.


The Rhoyne.


Asshai.


The North.


Valyria.


Dragons.


The decline of magic.


And then.


Aspera, who existed only in his own mind.


Daemon took out a fresh sheet of paper.


For some time, his pen did not move.


Then.


Very slowly.


He wrote one line.


『Can the Long Night return?』


Luwin’s eyes stopped on the sentence.


The room went quiet.


The candle flame flickered softly.


"Do you."


Luwin asked slowly.


"Believe that?"


Daemon did not answer at once.


Almost nothing they had discussed had been proven.


He had not even perfectly proven that the Long Night had been a real event.


The idea that free folk identity began in a political split after the Long Night was a hypothesis.


So was the idea that Brandon’s structures had been built through a single counteroffensive.


So was the connection between regional magic and ley lines.


So was the notion that the Doom of Valyria damaged the world’s magical network.


So was the idea that dragons had been catalysts sustaining faded magic.


So was the possibility that the Wall had already lost most of its function.


All of it.


Hypotheses.


"I do not know."


Daemon answered.


"Truly."


Luwin waited.


"If I say it is coming, I am mad."


A moment.


"But if I say it is not coming."


Another moment.


"There is no evidence for that either."


Daemon wrote beneath the question.


『Cannot be excluded.』


He thought a little.


Then beneath that.


『Therefore, it must be investigated.』


Luwin said, "That is a very large matter."


"It is not a conclusion."


Daemon shook his head.


"The problem is that there is no conclusion."


The chance might be very small.


One in a hundred.


One in ten thousand.


It might be lower still.


But if he could not even calculate the extent of the damage if it were true, he could not ignore it merely by looking at probability.


If he was wrong.


He read more books.


He had merely heard old tales from several free folk.


He wasted a little time.


That was all.


But if he was right and ignored it.


Daemon’s gaze turned north.


"Then we must investigate it."


Luwin asked, "Investigate what?"


Daemon looked at the stack of books.


"That is the problem."


Most of the materials he had now were later records.


Folktales.


Genealogies.


Maesters’ interpretations.


Songs passed down for thousands of years.


No matter how many books he read, original documents from the Long Night would not suddenly appear.


Then.


He would examine the site.


Daemon’s finger moved over the map.


Then.


Winterfell.


Luwin’s gaze followed.


"...Winterfell?"


"Yes."


Daemon leaned forward a little.


"Our discussion keeps converging there."


Brandon.


Stark.


The Long Night.


The Wall.


And then.


Winter is coming.


"If the texts can tell us no more, we must see it ourselves."


"What do you intend to see?"


"Beginning with the oldest parts."


Daemon began to curl his fingers, then stopped.


He had nearly made another list.


He simply lowered his hand.


"I will see how the walls added later differ from the original fortifications, read old records, and look at the hot springs and underground structures."


"Underground as well?"


"It is an ancient castle."


Luwin’s face grew uneasy.


"You do not mean to dismantle Winterfell, do you?"


"Am I mad?"


Luwin did not answer.


Daemon narrowed his eyes.


"Why are you not answering?"


"Continue."


"Anyway, I will only look."


Winterfell was a monstrously large castle.


Over thousands of years, it had been repaired.


Added to.


Torn down.


Built again.


Even Rickard Stark could not know the origins of every corner.


"If I dig around enough."


Luwin’s eyes immediately rose to him.


Daemon stopped.


"...If I investigate enough."


"Use that expression."


"Something old may have remained."


Luwin watched him briefly.


"Obtain formal permission."


"Of course."


The answer came too quickly.


Luwin narrowed his eyes.


"Why did you answer so quickly?"


"You are too suspicious."


"I learned it from you."


Daemon was briefly at a loss for words.


"...You turn it back on me like that."


Then another thought occurred to him.


Walls were repaired.


Towers changed.


As time passed, spaces where people lived could be altered however men wished.


Then what was the place later people found hardest to touch?


Daemon’s expression froze.


The graves of ancestors.


Winterfell had something below.


Stairs descending.


Descending again.


A vast crypt where the older a Stark was, the deeper they were said to be buried.


...Ah.


A place where traces older than the castle itself might remain.


A place where the Starks were believed to hold their post even in death.


And.


The thing that had been troubling him all this while.


House Stark had another, unofficial maxim.


There must always be a Stark in Winterfell.


Why must there always be one Stark left in Winterfell?


Was it truly only for the authority of the family?


Or.


What if.


What if the reason was connected to what lay beneath the castle?


Daemon immediately stopped himself.


I have gone too far.


No evidence.


Pure, high-grade delusion.


But.


He could verify it.


Then a small grey-eyed face appeared in his mind.


Lyanna.


The next instant.


No, you bastard.


Taking an eight-year-old child to investigate ancestral graves.


Once he made it into a sentence, it sounded even madder.


What if we just look around together?


Do not play with words.


Daemon cursed himself.


Luwin had silently watched all this.


"Lord Seadrake."


Daemon jerked his head up.


"Yes?"


"What were you just thinking?"


"I was not thinking anything."


"That is a lie."


"Why?"


"You had the expression you wear when you are thinking dangerous thoughts."


Daemon touched his cheek.


"There are categories for my expressions?"


"How many years have I watched you?"


"..."


Daemon quietly averted his eyes.


"I will not do anything."


"Truly?"


"For now."


Silence.


"Ah."


Daemon closed his eyes.


"I misspoke there."


Luwin sighed deeply.


Daemon drew a sheet of paper toward himself.


He roughly wrote down what to investigate at Winterfell.


The oldest fortifications.


Traces distinct from later additions.


Surviving old records.


The hot springs and underground structures.


Stark traditions concerning the Builder and the Long Night.


And then.


His pen stopped.


He hesitated for a long time.


Finally, he wrote one word.


『Crypts.』


Luwin saw it too.


The room was quiet for a moment.


"Lord Seadrake."


"What?"


"That is the underground tomb of House Stark."


"I know."


"It is not an empty cellar."


"I know that too."


"Then."


Daemon said with perfect calm, "We will look carefully."


Luwin closed his eyes.


"That is not what I mean."


"I did not say I would rob graves."


"The fact that I must feel relieved to hear you say that is itself the problem."


Daemon laughed softly.


Then he looked back at the map.


The Long Night.


Brandon.


Storm’s End.


Winterfell.


Stark.


The free folk.


The Wall.


Valyria.


Dragons.


And then.


Himself.


Things that had seemed to have no relation to one another were, strangely, converging northward one by one.


Daemon tapped Winterfell on the map with a finger.


"It seems."


Without opening his eyes, Luwin asked, "What is it?"


"I should go to Winterfell and have a look."


Luwin opened his eyes.


"Obtain formal permission."


"Of course."


"Again, you answered too quickly."


"You have no faith in me."


"I have grounds for it."


Daemon could not retort.


In any case, there was nothing unusual about going to Winterfell itself.


He went there about once every two months.


He saw Lyanna.


Ate with Rickard.


Staying several days before returning had become ordinary by now.


There was no reason not to see what nonsense Brandon was up to, either.


Outwardly.


It would be the visit he always made.


Only this time.


Daemon’s gaze slowly descended from Winterfell on the map.


Beneath the castle.


The place where Starks were said to have been buried for thousands of years.


The crypts.


And then.


Somewhere deeper still, something that might remain.


A reason.


But the question deeper still was one he could not tell even Luwin.


What, exactly, was he?


Why had he been born again after dying?


Why had it been a body with dragonlord blood?


Why had he been unable to bear being separated from a dragon egg from the moment of his birth?


And.


Why had the thing kings, princes, and sorcerers had failed at for more than a hundred years happened beside him?


Aspera had been born.


Perhaps.


Because he had grown.


And.


If that hypothesis was correct.


Magic might be growing stronger again as well.


Then.


Would only good things return?


Blue eyes surfaced in Daemon’s mind one last time.


The collapsing Wall.


And the being beyond it, looking south.


The smile vanished entirely from Daemon’s face.


The Long Night.


For now, it was a hypothesis.


Nothing more.


Nothing less.


But.


This time.


It was a hypothesis he hoped was wrong.

Comments (0)

Ch. 31: What Remained After the Fire Went Out
Font
Theme

Report Chapter Issue

Select an issue type and send your report.