[“This is a truly challenging question. Such an arrogant inquiry, probing the very foundations of magic, scarcely found an answer even in my era.”]
From within my coat, Eleanor poked her head out and scanned the document, offering a brief remark.
Beside her, Senior Selene leaned over the papers, her eyes sparkling as she chimed in.
{“What an astounding problem! It’s not merely about solving a convoluted formula; it’s questioning the very values by which we, as mages, define this world. I find myself thinking deeply without even realizing it.”}
“Hmm.”
The assessments of the two Archmages were precise.
This lay far closer to philosophy or mathematical logic than to physics.
It felt like the classic paradox of which came first, the chicken or the egg, dressed in magical terms.
‘I’m somewhat familiar with this field…’
In fact, during my undergraduate years in my previous life, I once became as absorbed in pure mathematical logic as I was in physics.
Thanks to that, I was quite at ease with metaphysical debates of this sort.
“…Lord Rihan? Do you perhaps have an inkling of the answer? Why do you look that way?”
Barman, having anxiously watched my expression, could no longer hold back and spoke up.
A subtle glint of expectation shone in his eyes.
Seeing me so fixated on the document, the director added, making assumptions.
“It must be difficult, right? Those arrogant old fogeys at the Magic Tower themselves swore it’d take at least a generation to solve! Even if you’re a genius, this will still need time…”
“I think I can solve it.”
My offhand reply cut his words short.
After a stunned silence, Barman’s eyes bulged.
“W-What did you say?! You really mean it? You’re not joking?!”
He lunged as if to grab me by the collar and shake me.
“How could that be possible?! Of course it’s you, Lord Rihan! I’ve believed in you from the very start!”
“……”
He never changes his tune.
Just moments ago, he was muttering that it was impossible.
At the slightest hint of possibility, he immediately burst into cheers.
“I’ll go in and verify it properly. If I’m on the right track, it could be done in no time.”
“Excellent! Splendid! Go confirm it at once! If you need anything, say the word! If you can humble those mages at the Magic Tower, I’ll even let you use my laboratory!”
“No need for your lab, sir…”
I left his fervent encouragement behind and headed to my senior laboratory.
*
Leaving the commotion behind, I entered my senior laboratory, where the subtle scent of roses brushed my nose.
In front of my desk sat Evelyn, having finished tidying the lab, seated in her chair.
“Lord Rihan, you’re here. How does the problem from the Magic Tower look?”
Evelyn rose from her chair and approached me.
“I think I can solve it. However, it will take some time.”
“Really? I looked at it too, and no matter how hard I stared, I couldn’t get a foothold. When you solve it, you must tell me first—I’m extremely curious.”
Curiosity gleamed in her eyes.
She seemed tremendously eager.
Well, of course.
She must delight in this kind of intellectual puzzle to have forsaken the Academy’s comforts for this stark lab.
“Certainly. Once I find a clue, you’ll be the very first to hear my explanation.”
“…Not anyone else, but me first, understood?”
“I promise.”
At my confident reply, Evelyn gave a small, triumphant smile.
“Thank you. I’ll drop by Celly’s lab briefly—there are still a few things to organize.”
She set down a steaming cup of coffee on my desk and added,
“To ask Celly? Is it about Academy matters?”
“Yes. And Celly has some questions about spell deployment methods. She’ll be back soon, so don’t get distracted.”
Having said that, Evelyn left the laboratory.
Hearing the door close, I felt a peculiar sense of satisfaction.
‘…Hmm. I like this.’
They seem to have grown quite close through the Academy’s recent events.
For Evelyn to make a friend…
Thinking of her original role as the solitary villainess makes it a truly moving change.
{“Oh my, our Evelyn has become so mature—making friends is delightful!”}
Senior Selene hovered in midair, gazing at the door with a bright smile.
‘Isn’t that right? I’m moved too.’
Now she can proudly claim she’s not the villainess, can’t she?
I tucked away my pleased feelings and sank deep into the sofa.
Then, I turned to the formidable problem Barman had handed me.
I began to read carefully the so-called Problem of Truth posed by the Magic Tower.
----------
[Problem of Truth: The First Metaphysical Axiom — Ontological Proof of [Arcane Path]]
■ Proposition: Are the schemata and language that produce magical phenomena predetermined truths inscribed at the origin of the world, or are they artificial fictions crafted by an intelligent being projecting its will onto the chaotic energy called mana?
■ Core argument:
1. If magic is a discovery, then intelligent beings merely observe preexisting laws, and mages are nothing more than the world’s servants.
2. If magic is an invention, then every magic system we use is but a grand mirage molded from mana clay, with no absolute truth beneath it.
■ Requirement: Prove, through magical logic, whether the magical computational framework can demonstrate its own completeness without external involvement, or whether it necessarily requires the presupposition of an external absolute law to exist.
----------
“This question is even more challenging than I thought.”
The very intent behind the problem casts doubt on the essence of magic.
[“This is indeed a rather provocative question.”]
“Exactly. In some ways, it’s quite a radical inquiry.”
[“Even in my era, few would dare to pose a question of such magnitude. Fortunately, magical thought has not remained stagnant in later generations.”]
The Archmage who had ascended to the realm of transcendence regarded the Magic Tower’s challenge as remarkably high caliber.
“Senior, what do you think? From the perspective of a Tenth-Tier Archmage, which side seems correct?”
At my question, Eleanor nodded and answered.
[“Lord Rihan, I traversed the threshold of the origin itself. Magic, in its essence, existed within the world. It flowed long before any intelligent being discovered it—this is my conviction.”]
One can scarcely imagine the worldview at the height of the Tenth Tier.
Yet her words were filled with unwavering certainty.
“Of course. That must be correct. It’s the most romantic answer for mages.”
At that moment, Senior Selene interjected playfully.
{“Oh my, you speak as if you already know the answer! Yet the mages of the Magic Tower themselves seem to harbor doubts that their constructed magic systems are but castles built on sand.”}
Selene’s insight was sharp.
They must have posed this problem driven by a fundamental suspicion of the ivory tower they themselves erected.
I slowly scanned the problem once more.
The debate felt familiar even on a second glance.
This was the very dispute that, in my past life, Plato’s [Theory of Forms] and the Formalists had grappled with for millennia.
In brief, it goes like this.
Does the perfect concept of a triangle already exist somewhere in the cosmos, waiting for us to find it?
Or did we merely join three sticks end to end and then call the result a triangle?
The question is which of the two is correct.
If the former is true, then mages are akin to priests uncovering the world’s truth.
If the latter, they are little more than cunning monkeys adept at wielding tools.
In this world, magic generally resides in the realm of mysticism.
To mages, magic is an absolute truth to be discovered, not a human fabrication wrestled into shape at will.
To ask whether our magic is “a fiction we ourselves created” borders on sacrilege.
It may be a question no one at the Magic Tower would ever dare to ask if they weren’t enthralled by their own authority.
But to my eyes, the substance of this question was not mysticism.
It lay squarely in the domain of mathematical axiomatics.
“Hmm…”
I have a rough sense of the direction this logic must take.
But because the subject is not pure mathematics but magic itself, the mapping process seemed trickier than expected.
I picked up my fountain pen and began twirling it between my fingers.
Though I did not voice it aloud, memories from my past life swirled in my mind.
I paused the pen’s spin and began jotting formulas one by one into the margins.
In truth, such a problem had already been proven.
It was during the world war of my previous life.
An age of madness when all intellect grew at an abnormal rate amid the volleys of warfare.
Mathematics was no exception.
All the geniuses of Earth had gathered in the city of Vienna in Austria.
There, scholars of the greatest stature of the day, including Einstein, reveled in discussion.
At the heart of that chaos where logic and philosophy intertwined explosively…
Emerged the theorem that forever altered the course of human intellectual history.
The content of that theorem was simple.
No matter how perfect a logical system appears, there will always exist propositions within it that the system itself cannot prove to be true or false.
It was Kurt Gödel’s [Gödel’s Incompleteness Theorem].
Comments (0)
Please log in to leave a comment. Login or Register